Re:The Government's $200,000 Useless Android Application
by Tichy on Tuesday November 22, 2011 @01:37PM
(#3266726)
Maybe they should have created a competition for finished apps instead. If the app is as simple as it sounds (not sure what it actually does), maybe some high school kids would have entered a better version and raked in 5000$ as the first price.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The Government's $200,000 Useless Android Application
by pavel_lishin on Tuesday November 22, 2011 @01:52PM
(#3266798)
What test would they use to check whether an app is simple or not? At a certain point, you put out a bid for a complicated monstrocity, and the only entrant is some RentACoder who claims he can re-write Windows in Python in two weeks for $50.
Re:The Government's $200,000 Useless Android Application
by Tichy on Tuesday November 22, 2011 @02:52PM
(#3267055)
Since the competition would be for finished apps, it wouldn't matter.
Re:The Government's $200,000 Useless Android Application
by pavel_lishin on Tuesday November 22, 2011 @03:25PM
(#3267178)
Sure it would. If OSHA wants a new operating system, putting out an open call for a deliverable would be retarded. Absolutely nobody would be able to deliver such a thing on spec, and those that would be willing would be obvious scam artists.
At best, it would cost someone a few weeks of time evaluating these bullshit submissions and realizing that they're a waste of time. At worst, they would be accepted, another $100k would be paid out, and we'd be worse off than when we began.
Re:The Government's $200,000 Useless Android Application
by Tichy on Tuesday November 22, 2011 @03:36PM
(#3267234)
We were talking about some temperature app, not a new operating system. I did not suggest such a competition would be a good idea for every kind of project.
It's true that there would be overhead for running the competition and judging the entries, too.
Re:The Government's $200,000 Useless Android Application
by pavel_lishin on Tuesday November 22, 2011 @04:59PM
(#3267580)
> We were talking about some temperature app, not a new operating system. I did not suggest such a competition would be a good idea for every kind of project.
Right, I was trying to raise the point that it's not always obvious where the line between "trivial app" and "major project" should be drawn.
Re:The Government's $200,000 Useless Android Application
by gte910h on Tuesday November 22, 2011 @04:03PM
(#3267353)
This is an app to prevent heat death. That's completely inappropriate to have a contest for.
Re:The Government's $200,000 Useless Android Application
by Tichy on Tuesday November 22, 2011 @04:09PM
(#3267375)
I didn't read too closely - isn't it basically an app that reminds you to drink water on a regular basis? Why not have a contest for that?
In fact why not have contests about stuff that saves lives?