News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Software engineering research questions by seanhunter on Wednesday August 31, 2022 @01:05AM (#32658567)
I'd love to see (or do myself if I ever get the chance) some research into some of the hot-button software architecture, tooling and project structure topics that come up a lot here and in every team I've worked on. They always boil down to a religious debate with strong opinions on all sides, and everyone wanting to copy something they've read about how their favourite MAGMA company does it, but it feels like some of these should have empirically right answers:

1. Under what circumstances is a monorepo beneficial as opposed to multiple smaller repos and what are the determining factors? (Team size, codebase size, tooling, software coupling, project velocity, .... etc?)

2. Under what circumstances are different system architectures better, and what are all the different factors that influence this? (eg microservices, 3-tier, one big blob of code, ... etc)

3. Can we empirically measure or determine whether a language, framework, library etc is the right choice for a given situation and how might we do that? Is it possible to formulate rules to inform good decisions here or is it always going to be a matter of judgement?

4. How do different styles of working (Pair programming, scrum, TDD etc) affect team productivity, code quality, developer happiness, project velocity etc? What are the factors that make one preferable over another in a given situation?

5. What's the right team size for a given project?

6. What's the best way to discover and communicate software requirements?

...

I could go on. But in other engineering disciplines, a lot of the analogous things are solved problems rather than being topics for heated debate.

Re:Software engineering research questions by bee_rider on Wednesday August 31, 2022 @10:38AM (#32662593)
Thought somebody had tried to commercialize MAGMA for a second.

https://icl.utk.edu/magma/

Re:Software engineering research questions by gyulai on Wednesday August 31, 2022 @01:10AM (#32658591)
> ... favourite MAGMA company ...

What's "MAGMA"?

Re:Software engineering research questions by FridgeSeal on Wednesday August 31, 2022 @01:14AM (#32658622)
Like FAANG but more Meta.
Re:Software engineering research questions by seanhunter on Wednesday August 31, 2022 @01:20AM (#32658666)
Yeah exactly. Meta, Alphabet, Google, Microsoft, Apple[1] or permutations thereof.

Basically you pick the initialism and then you choose companies that plausibly could fit into it.

[1] Edit: errrr, that doesn't quite work does it. Meta, Amazon, Google, Microsoft, Apple lets say.

Re:Software engineering research questions by BerislavLopac on Wednesday August 31, 2022 @03:49AM (#32659508)
Oh, that's a nice one - definitely way better than FAANG!

That being said, I think that Meta is evil and should not be promoted in any way - so we might go for a version without it, for example MAGA! Oh, wait... :P

Re:Software engineering research questions by kinow on Wednesday August 31, 2022 @01:26AM (#32658700)