As an AI practitioner, if I could so easily bottle up taste and sell it, I surely would.
And would you lie to protect it?
Snuffaluffagus
You're the aggressive one by my book :)
To me taste is subjective and ill-posed. I accept that people have the right to their own personal tastes.
What would you lie to protect?
If people can make art out of literal garbage, I think they can make art by manipulating a Turing-complete class of machines (recall that LLMs can perform program synthesis).
I agree that naive and even not-so-naive usage of AI tools will mostly be artistically superficial, but I believe that (some) people will break through the creative limitations inherent in the copycat nature of this machinery.
Now maybe thats okay. Maybe there is no need to lie about it. If there is paranoia, it doesnt come from me I believe.
Seriously, I don’t know that. According to Statistica, the total value of fine art transactions was over $65 billion in 2021. But fine, let’s take it as stipulated: commercial art is a far bigger market.
If there really is that much at stake, change is inevitable.
“It doesnt. And you know it. It only takes taste. Which is very easy for an AI to acquire with intelligent supervision. It will be way better than the 99 percentile of artists very quickly. The rest is monkey work and is worth nothing.”
You are (aggressively) psychic! As an AI practitioner, if I could so easily bottle up taste and sell it, I surely would. Supervised learning requires a source, and current methods require vast (and thus expensive) corpora of training data. The better it understands what is “good” by the standards of that data set, the less ability it has to generate novel work and redefine what is, in fact, good.
Visual style, in particular, is subject to fashions whim, what ML practitioners call “concept drift.” What is exalted one day, is scorned and ridiculed in another.
If taste were so easily captured in a model, Hollywood would never have to worry about making another bomb. Game studio executives could sleep blissfully. A vast amount of money is lost due to bad design choices, across countless industries. Frankly, I think a Taste Oracle is worth more than an AI Snuffaluffagus.
“One of the first things I noticed on the SD website is the cleverness of the bullshit. With "ethic" and stuff everywhere. Did you wrote it? Are you CEO?”
I am just not that clever. I see all that as CYA. The fact that they released everything, code and models, undermines the notion that they expect to corner a multi-trillion dollar market.
Paranoia, anger, aggression, maybe this is appropriate in the face of unknowable change. But people are divided at the outset of this revolution, and remain conquered by the future Mars dwellers.
To clarify, I work (Earthbound) in Computer Vision and Perception; my preference is for concrete problems.