That suggests that there is no other material contributor to mortality from obesity[1], which is a somewhat unexpected result.
--
[1] it is possible that there are negative contributions to mortality associated with obesity which could potentially "hide" other positive contributors
(Leaving out the discussion: effects to environment, sedentary lifestyle, etc)
For example, tall people tend to have higher BMI, as if 2 is not the right power to raise height to. But you barely need a 4-op calculator to calculate that. Good luck calculating BMI if the power were 2.18 or whatever gives best fit.
Measuring body fat is not exactly hard but much less straightforward and a touch unpleasant. If you're running a large study, it's much easier to measure BMI than anything else. At population level, I'd imagine correlation to obesity is easily 80-90%.
I guess it is also easier for doctors to say "your BMI is too high" rather than "you're too rounded".
But he is an athlete with almost no fat (he is not aiming at muscles so he does not have a diet that minimizes fat, he is looking for sheer power and explosivity (gym, martial arts)). He is very built up (muscular) though.
So I wonder how the BMI can give any kind of reasonable indication when the fat level is not taken into account.
Without any consideration for fat BMI doe snot make much sense I guess.
Sure BMI can be more or less accurate depending on the person, but for those few who have actually rendered it inapplicable to them it's going to be blatantly obvious. No one will confuse them with being obese.
I wouldn’t have been obese before, but I technically am now (with reduced bodyfat %).
Fat is not the only way to be heavy, body builders have very high BMI value yet have very different risk profiles.
Also, I'm still confused. My previous understanding was that bodybuilders are classified as obese without having excess body fat because they fit into that ratio because the ratio doesn't account for exceptions. Not that obesity actually incorporates more than just a ratio.
The point about body builders is that BMI as a metric assumes a fixed muscular profile, so doing (an healthy amount of) muscle training can wildly affect your BMI independently of your fatness.
If is still likely a good measure at a population level as very few people that have BMI > 30 are also fit. But you need to contextualize it to your own case.
If you look at a bunch of variables, including BMI, and then you remove the impact of well known negative health impacts of obesity (prediabetes/T2D), then you see that high BMI doesn't not correlate well with mortality. IMO, what this indicates to me is that (1) BMI is not a good indicator of obesity in this study. There are many healthy people with low body fat and high BMI, I am one of them. All you need to do is be tall and lift weights occasionally. If you remove the obesity related negative health signals, you also remove obesity(2) Being fat in and of itself is not the issue, the issue is prediabetes/T2D which is extremely reliably caused by obesity, and the treatment for prediabetes/T2D is weight loss.