> And "total mission success" isn't the only goal of these programs. Progress in manufacturing and engineering is a considerable factor.
This is such a copout and nonsense. The idea that SLS does anything for 'progress in manufacturing and engineering' is a bad senator talking point with essentially no relevant for the real world.
In fact, giving money to innovative space companies would achieve those things far better.
> Governments, like big banks, are better at taking on risk
The whole point of SLS was that it was low risk legacy technology. SLS is the EXACT LITERAL opposite of what you suggest, its low-risk incredibly conservative with minimal technological advancement.
Up until recently, there was no profit motive to create private rockets, so the government was the only source of work on rockets. The government doesn't need that many rockets, so it's not shocking that there are a small number of contractors.
And no, you can't just force them to shoulder risk. They're private companies that aren't contractually obligated to accept other contracts. If we wanted someone we could force risk onto, we would need a public entity that designs and manufactures the rockets.
Or rather, I guess we could legislatively force them to accept the risk, but I would expect private capital to flee, so it would become a de facto public organization.
Just look at the journey COTS, form Orbital -> Orbital ATK -> NG.
> Up until recently, there was no profit motive to create private rockets
Had the government not artificially pushed Shuttle, there would actually have been a quite large commercial market.
A US launch vehicle could very much have competed against Ariane 3 and Soyuz.
> And no, you can't just force them to shoulder risk.
Rocket launches in the 90s were not some crazy future risk. Doing a COTS style program for rockets was 100% viable.
> If we wanted someone we could force risk onto, we would need a public entity that designs and manufactures the rockets.
No you only need a public entity willing to buy a a lot of launches.
And "total mission success" isn't the only goal of these programs. Progress in manufacturing and engineering is a considerable factor.
Governments, like big banks, are better at taking on risk than most businesses or individual persons. That's how health care works in most civilized countries, disaster relief and other things. And expensive space programs had to be started by governments because they were too risky with too little benefit, and in some respects this is still the case.