News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Should grapefruit juice have warning labels for m... by samstave on Sunday August 28, 2022 @02:23PM (#32630658)
YES!!!!

They should.

-

My grandmother was an ER nurse her whole life (a candy-striper, etc, malpractice insurance investigations etc...)

she was on some medications and grapefruit was a staple morning breakfast for my grandmother and grandfather... Grapefruit, a small sprinkle of either sugar or salt and a glass of O.J. - every morning for like 40 years....

Nearly killed her after she was on some medication that had a poor interaction with grapefruit.

and these were medical experts!

So, _YES_

EDIT: The point is: that even if youre a medical expert, you're still susceptible to this problem, and SHE WAS AWARE but the thing was that a medication she took at like 75 years old, was NOT properly warned about...

Jeasus folks, even brilliant people miss shit like this at times.

Re:Ask HN: Should grapefruit juice have warning labels for m... by oyashirochama on Sunday August 28, 2022 @02:28PM (#32630711)
Is it not the responsibility of the doctor prescribing or the very least the person who is taking the medication to be aware? They put warnings on all medication that has interactions with grapefruit, because they don't want to check a piece of paper on their prescription or mention to their doctor of their diet.

It's your body, your health ultimately, in hand with the doctors support.

How would you even mark fresh fruit? Force supermarkets, farmers, why stop there?

Re:Ask HN: Should grapefruit juice have warning labels for m... by thombat on Sunday August 28, 2022 @02:35PM (#32630772)
So every day for 40 years she would have read and thought carefully about that warning label, so that finally when it became relevant it would save her? Unfortunately not: we humans cope with the enormous stream of information pouring relentlessly through our senses by ignoring almost any unchanging signal. In industries requiring constant awareness for rare events, such as piloting highly automated aircraft or scanning luggage for bombs, we've learnt to present constant challenges (fake alerts, etc) to keep the operators paying attention. See also: safely driving a Tesla on autopilot...
Re:Ask HN: Should grapefruit juice have warning labels for m... by dehrmann on Sunday August 28, 2022 @02:26PM (#32630699)
Are you sure she would have even see it? After eating grapefruit for 40 years, she'd become accustomed to ignoring the warning. She wouldn't have thought this warning suddenly applied to her.
Re:Ask HN: Should grapefruit juice have warning labels for m... by samstave on Sunday August 28, 2022 @02:44PM (#32630852)
New medications come to market and are not properly labled and the person in question who was a medical expert, was retired at the time - so she wasnt tracking product lit etc...
Re:Ask HN: Should grapefruit juice have warning labels for m... by tsimionescu on Sunday August 28, 2022 @03:02PM (#32631000)
Yes, and she would have seen the same warning on the grapefruit juice that she had been seeing for 40 years - which would have helped her not at all.

Or do you think the warning would be kept up to date with the brand names (since many people don't know the substance names, of course) of the hundreds or thousands of medications that interact with grapefruit, and that people would periodically read that list?

This is 100% on the doctor that prescribed the medication, a label on the juice or the fruit would do less than nothing, especially for people who consume it regularly.

Re:Ask HN: Should grapefruit juice have warning labels for m... by sokoloff on Sunday August 28, 2022 @02:59PM (#32630981)
How would this new medication appear on the interaction label on all grapefruits/juice containers if your claim is that a medication itself made it all the way to market without the proper labeling on that very medication?
Re:Ask HN: Should grapefruit juice have warning labels for m... by svnt on Sunday August 28, 2022 @02:56PM (#32630956)
If you think ER nurses are medical experts I don’t know what to say. They are medical assistants and specialists who do not prescribe medications — they do what the doctor says.
Re:Ask HN: Should grapefruit juice have warning labels for m... by wizofaus on Sunday August 28, 2022 @03:00PM (#32630990)
Maybe that's true in your part of the world but at least in Australia nurses play a crucial role in double checking whether medication directives/dosages actually make sense, and knowing what to do when patients have allergic reactions or appear to have been mis-prescribed certain drugs. Doctors make at most high level decisions about courses of treatment (even for chemotherapy) and rely on the experience and responsibility of nurses to ensure they're delivered safely and effectively.

(Source: watching my partner do online professional competency tests. Definitely expert level knowledge required.)

Re:Ask HN: Should grapefruit juice have warning labels for m... by svnt on Sunday August 28, 2022 @08:04PM (#32633433)
Yes your partner is a medical specialist. I have also had partners who were nurses. My statement is still correct.

There is no such thing as a “medical expert” as the term is over broad and eg ER nurses are not required to advise patients on interactions of prescription medications.

That falls to the doctor and likely pharmacist.

It does not surprise me at all that a former ER nurse doesn’t know that some medication she got prescribed interacts with grapefruit juice.

Re:Ask HN: Should grapefruit juice have warning labels for m... by wizofaus on Monday August 29, 2022 @04:50AM (#32636048)
She's a registered nurse shrug. And yes she's worked ER.
Re:Ask HN: Should grapefruit juice have warning labels for m... by samstave on Sunday August 28, 2022 @06:11PM (#32632573)
Hi. My grandmother knows more about medicine than you will ever know, my brother was the Commander of the tenth medical wing for USAF and had over 10,000 service members and their families under his care - director of the VA and currently runs the largest hospital group in a particular state... (Timothy Dean Ballard, MD Col. USAF - if you care to fact check my bullshit) and the personal flight surgeon to the joint chiefs at the pentagon (general Shelton)... Ive built more hospitals than you have stepped in....

My aunt is the head NICU nurse at El Camino Hospital in Mountain View Ca, (the hospital of the future) one of the many hospitals I built... (el Camino, UCSF, SFGH, Sequoia, Nome, Methodist) yeah im a little closer to this subject than you may have assumed.

And if you think an ER nurse "just does what a doctor says"

You know absolutely nothing of top nurses. They wear the pants.

I'm comfortable with my statement. So, thankfully you don't know what to say.

Re:Ask HN: Should grapefruit juice have warning labels for m... by svnt on Sunday August 28, 2022 @08:00PM (#32633414)
I am close with several ICU and cardiac nurses. They are experts at what they do, so in a sense you could call them medical experts.

However they are medical experts in the same way that a plumber is a construction expert. I would not be surprised if a plumber was caught off guard by lighting codes.

The term is so broad as to be meaningless in practical application.

Re:Ask HN: Should grapefruit juice have warning labels for m... by samstave on Monday August 29, 2022 @06:02AM (#32636388)
>>"_cardiac nurses_"

-

Please share this joke with them, this is from Dr. Francis Stutzman, Cardiologist and mayor of Saratoga Ca..

--

>"I've got good news!!! and bad news"

>>You're _heart_ is going to last you the rest of your life!!

>>>"Sadly, thats going to be about a week."

Re:Ask HN: Should grapefruit juice have warning labels for m... by samstave on Sunday August 28, 2022 @08:20PM (#32633522)
Cool. I dont have a medical degree - but I can design hospitals (and have) so your approximation of knowledge/ability to the problem at hand is meaningless.
[dead]
Re:Ask HN: Should grapefruit juice have warning labels for m... by samstave on Sunday August 28, 2022 @10:49PM (#32634299)
You have literally no idea how much impact an individual can have on a project....(We typically call them 'Architects'...)

but your scorn is well met ; It DOES take a team of countless -- and I have also been literally the sole designer of things that relied on thousands to implement.

Thanks for your disinterest.