What is true is that NYC is becoming a place that matters for technology businesses. We could talk all day about scale (corps vs. startups vs. schools vs. many other things) but the bottom line is that NYC has a real technology sector and it's growing.
I would also ask why compare at all? These are apples and oranges. Let Silicon Valley have its claim to fame and don't try to make NYC fit into this mold that it clearly doesn't belong in. NYC has its special qualities. So let's applaud them and encourage them to keep doing what they do best and let them develop their own culture or claim to fame instead of comparing the two.
I honestly do agree there, but as we all know here, there's VC and angels who have all their investments clustered around Castro and Uni in the valley, so that they can walk to all their portfolio companies in the span of one day.
Seriously, you're all smart people. Why is the fact that New York City is a completely unacceptable place to live not a consideration here?
NYC has its downsides just like every place on earth does. Paradise doesn't exist. We each have to find or make out own and I can respect that some people love New York even if I don't. The suburbs can be thought of as full of soccer moms, yuppies, the unhip or less intelligent, there's nothing to do, everything is far away, and on and on. Some like it. It's a good place to raise a family or at least there's a good argument for it.
It's all relative. Everything is relative. Very few things aren't.
AllTheImportantBits
1. NYC has overtaken Boston as a VC hub.
2. Bloomberg is trying to get a really great Tech University.
3. Living in New York is very attractive compared to living in Suburbia with great weather (Silicon Valley).