Legibility is vastly improved in the readability-powered version (upper-left button).
Your point still stands, of course.
Re:Smooth CoffeeScript
by autotelicum on Monday November 21, 2011 @04:46AM
(#3260569)
Good constructive feedback. I thought about it, so one of the next days when I get time, I'll add a little 'Limit Width' button up on top. It'll be freeflow by default, but just one click for those who prefer a narrower format.
Don't leap so quickly to making it a user choice. Just 'Do The Right Thing'. In this case I think enforcing a max width is 'The Right Thing'.
If you disagree then that'a ace but take the responsibility for your own defaults.
The right thing is free-width of course. You have a personal need for narrow lines - no problem.
But a lot more people than you realize do not like narrow lines.
Re:Smooth CoffeeScript
by ericmoritz on Sunday November 20, 2011 @05:05PM
(#3259139)
Just shrink your window if you want 80 chars per line, jeez.
Re:Smooth CoffeeScript
by inconditus on Sunday November 20, 2011 @05:16PM
(#3259165)
I'm not sure if you're being sarcastic, but the parent was offering advice for accessibility to help the member's of the community improve on their projects. Why would you disapprove of that?
I personally hate when sites make the text narrow. If I want the text narrow, I shrink the browser. (Which I never actually do BTW.)
So to me the advice makes things worse, not better. 60-80 chars per line???? Even my email is wider than that. Go for at least 200.
Re:Smooth CoffeeScript
by dextorious on Monday November 21, 2011 @12:33PM
(#3261911)
Sure, for some reason standard typographic practice and tons of readability tests that show the need for narrower lines don't apply to you especially.
And? I think it's a lot more people than you realize - at the moment my comment has 7 points, and that's despite getting downmodded a few times.
This stuff with narrow lines may have been tested on poor readers perhaps? I don't know. All I know is I hate narrow lines - and I especially hate them on websites.
Re:Smooth CoffeeScript
by dextorious on Tuesday November 22, 2011 @11:05AM
(#3265992)
I mostly attribute it to self-delusion.
Also, none of those 7 even did a proper A/B/A test on what they claim --while the counter-example is well shown in tons of tests.
Re:Smooth CoffeeScript
by chicagobob on Monday November 21, 2011 @01:26AM
(#3260226)
This, a thousand times this.
I know you love your fluid-width layouts, but just because you can fill the entire window with content, doesn't mean you have to. Blocks of text become difficult to read (and also ugly) when lines get to a certain length. The rule of thumb is that about 60-80 characters per line is comfortable. On my display, this site has about 250 characters per line and it makes me want to hit the back button. Yes, I can use Readability, but that strips out the code formatting. Simple fix: put a containing div around your content, and set a max-width on that container.
See Jashkenas's work for examples of well-formatted technical writing:
http://jashkenas.github.com/coffee-script/
http://jashkenas.github.com/coffee-script/documentation/docs...
Anyway, looks like a nice resource. Thanks for sharing.