News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A near 100% renewables grid is well within reach, and wit... by Schroedingersat on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @01:56PM (#32583221)
For the cost of 5kW nameplate of new western nuclear (>$10/W) you can get, right now, at retail, as an individual: 50kW nameplate of solar, and 8kW nameplate of wind, and 75kWh of storage and a 5kW generator (which will almost never need turning on) and a biogas digester.

And it will produce enough excess power to replace itself (with a cheaper version) or just triple the batteries if you can get 2-3c/kWh for the surplus well before the reactor is built

Mentioning nuclear as an option is about as sensible as a generator bicycle.

Re:A near 100% renewables grid is well within reach, and wit... by ZeroGravitas on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @02:01PM (#32583292)
I wouldn't advocate for new nuclear (for the same reason the creator of this model gives, it just isn't cost effective) but existing nuclear in stable, northern regions that also have hydro is definately a positive if you're aiming to get to carbon-free power faster.

If you don't have the much hydro then it can fight with solar/wind for usage of that dispatchable resource, and if you don't have the nuclear you can build solar/wind for less so there's no reason to start.

Re:A near 100% renewables grid is well within reach, and wit... by Schroedingersat on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @02:28PM (#32583718)
Agreed. Keep the current nuclear on as long as it's safe and doesn't cost more than eg. a new green ammonia build.
Re:A near 100% renewables grid is well within reach, and wit... by trashtester on Thursday August 25, 2022 @12:42PM (#32596314)
This report provides costs for nuclear power down to about $30/MWH (LCOE) at 3% discount rate (interest rate - inflation rate):

https://www.oecd-nea.org/upload/docs/application/pdf/2020-12...

Most countries should be able to reach such levels if providing guarantees for the credit, removing overly excessive regulation and allowing the most capable and experienced construction companies to lead construction and initial operations, especially if large enough numbers are built that economies of scale kick in.

Renewables-only systems (apart from hydro, where available), are not able to provide constant power output at anything near such levels yet, without a significant percentage of the power being generated by natural gas.

Massive capital investments in the grid, hydrogen generation, etc, MAY be able to actually provide stable power, but would be very unlikely to match nuclear if nuclear is optimized for price.

This could change in a few years, obviously, especially if storage becomes super cheap. But there is no guarantee of that.

As for the astronomical costs of some recent nuclear plants in western countries, those are a bit like evaluating the price of electric cars based on the Tesla Model S Plaid. We can get perfectly serviceable plants for a fraction of the price, by removing most of the bells and whistles, while still making sure that they are safer than most of the plants in operation today.

Re:A near 100% renewables grid is well within reach, and wit... by Schroedingersat on Thursday August 25, 2022 @10:52PM (#32602833)
There are a couple of problems with that analysis.

Firstly I am very sceptical of their 60 year claim with an additional 20 years for LTO. Every time I look a supposed 60 year reactor in the west up it is having major problems after less than 40 -- I'd be interested in seeing a survey of reactors broken down by location (china is provably much more cost efficient at doing large projects than anyone else albeit at a high human cost) and whether they're funded by geopolitical incentives (russia subsidizing reactors to induce energy dependence). Additionally half of the reactor lifetime is irrelevant to meeting 2050 targets even if we take design lifetime as true.

Even if we take the $30/MWh as an assumption. There are solar projects completing right now on the order of 80c/fixed Watt or $1.2 tilting. These produce 5-6 and 6-8 kWh/day/kW respectively.

Ending the day with half of that production in a battery nets you an LCOE around $50 and that is falling by 15%/year with little indication of slowing down.

Wind is a similar story (although not dropping as precipitously) and moderately anti-correlated.

When 'we promise we can reduce the price by 3x and we'll follow through on that promise for 70 years even though costs have been going up and we've never followed through before' is a pretty hard sell against 'we've been consistently dropping costs for 10 years at a rate that will make even the most optimistic projections of nuclear look expensive before you can build even the first one'. Then with the shorter lived renewables you get your money back after 10-20 years, and cna spend it on a new system that is $3/MWh (or more likely 10 as land and coupling costs will dominate).

And then there's all the geopolitical problems going nuclear entails for the large portion of the world who aren't allowed to make their own fuel. We did that with fossil fuels and it was awful -- and they can be refined by more than 5 countries.

Re:A near 100% renewables grid is well within reach, and wit... by trashtester on Friday August 26, 2022 @04:50AM (#32604807)
> (china is provably much more cost efficient at doing large projects than anyone else albeit at a high human cost)

Tesla and SpaceX is proving that with the right leadership, western countries can also do large projects. Anyway, I think we should let international corporations compete for such projects, kind of like ship construction or more remotely, the car industry.

> Ending the day with half of that production in a battery nets you an LCOE around $50 and that is falling by 15%/year with little indication of slowing down.

That is great, and I'm a huge believer in solar for many purposes in suitable climates. Where I live, though, we have about 4-6 hours of faint daylight in the middle of winter, when it's really cold.

Also, unlike nuclear, no country has so far been able to demonstrate an electrical grid that is powered exclusively by renewables (and Europe has tried). So far, everyone who tried, ended up with a huge reliance on (mostly Russian) natural gas, while having prices quite a bit above $50/MWH LCOE (for the grid as a hole). Currently, consumer facing prices are above $500/MWH, and may reach $1000/MWH this winter.

If some country wants to invest in a plan to make them independent of natural gas without nuclear, I wish them the best of luck, but in my opinion, nuclear is the proven path. Also, it's not like one cannot do both at the same time.

> Wind is a similar story (although not dropping as precipitously) and moderately anti-correlated.

Wind also has longer variance in supply. To some extent, making a grid the size of Australia may lower the variance, but at the cost of a grid that competes with nuclear in zero day investment costs while bringing its own set of political risks (especially in places where the grid needs to span many countries with different cultures).

> spend it on a new system that is $3/MWh

With all due respect, this is a fantasy number. When you're not including the storage and/or distribution needed to provide stable supply, this number means nothing. (Or rather, it's only relevant as long as only a small fraction of the power comes from such a source.)

Actual costs (LCOE, including enough enough storage to provide stable supply) are much higher. Different estimates exist. Your $50/MWh is probably the lowest I've seen. Typically I see $100-$200/MWH when including moderate storage, and several times that (up to $1000/MWH) when including enough storage to last several days with very little wind.

From my point of view, paying $30-$50/MWH for stable electricity production, with the lowest carbon emissions (construction emissions for concrete, etc, are about the same as the best renewables), low dependence on minerals that are in short supply (rare earths, etc) using proven technology is quite fair.

Hopefully, renewables, thorium, fusion etc will continue to develop to a point where they become clearly superior to nuclear in terms of price. But if so, I see that as a potential upside. Building more nuclear provides a hedge against the risk that this will take a long time.

> And then there's all the geopolitical problems going nuclear entails for the large portion of the world who aren't allowed to make their own fuel.

It's not for every country, but unlike natural gas, there are enough deposits in stable democratic western countries to power all such countries.

Also, there are alternatives sources for China and Russia to not worry too much about the risk either. India, being somewhat in-between these worlds would probably be able to source fuel from at least one.

And unlike natural gas, transporting nuclear fuel is quite trivial, due to the energy density.

Finally, it's not like we need to have 100% of one source of energy. Some should probably go mostly renewable (Australia, for example), due to climate. Some already have plenty of hydro, and some would benefit from having more (or much more) nuclear.

Some might also need to go for fossil fuels, at least as backup. I'm thinking of smaller islands, for instance (like Hawaii). But it would be good if we could soon start to REDUCE the dependence on fossil fuels, instead of consuming more and more every year, globally.

Re:A near 100% renewables grid is well within reach, and wit... by Schroedingersat on Friday August 26, 2022 @08:28AM (#32606500)
> With all due respect, this is a fantasy number. When you're not including the storage and/or distribution needed to provide stable supply, this number means nothing. (Or rather, it's only relevant as long as only a small fraction of the power comes from such a source.)

Distribution will dominate at some point, you are correct. This was more meant to be illustrative of how current battery and solar prices look from the point of view of the market that existed when just finished nuclear projects were approved. $50/MWh with 4 hours storage would look just as crazy from the POV of 2006

Speaking of distribution. 80% of the world's population lives at a lower latitude than washington DC, and about 90% of the remainder is within 2000km. Over this distance HVDC is a viable transport method with costs commensurable to $10-20/MWh. The main issue is security (both political/market and against disaster). For areas without sufficient hydro a reserve of green ammonia or (even physical transport) could be viable.

> Currently, consumer facing prices are above $500/MWH, and may reach $1000/MWH this winter.

Green hydrogen is scalable at about $400/MWh presently and this is decreasing rapidly. This was a wakeup call that doing so is needed. Ammonia is not far behind. Realistic projections for the next 8 years are around $100/MWh.

Combined with short term storage, this makes the $50/MWh with ~unbounded buffer seem pretty achievable by 2030 if sodium batteries and perovskites (or equivalent improvements) are scaled.

Re:A near 100% renewables grid is well within reach, and wit... by trashtester on Friday August 26, 2022 @11:33AM (#32608816)
> Green hydrogen is scalable at about $400/MWh presently and this is decreasing rapidly. This was a wakeup call that doing so is needed. Ammonia is not far behind. Realistic projections for the next 8 years are around $100/MWh.

The present price is obviously too high. I fully support any investment into this kind of tech, including from the government(s), though in my experience, even when tech is available, it takes time to roll it out.

Maybe by 2050 we will have the ability to provide stable, fully renewable energy at $50/MWh or below, without being limited in how much we can roll out due to some rare mineral or industrial capacity.

But we KNOW we have the tech to produce nuclear at such levels (or below) already.

In my opinion, we should do both, and if, 30-40 years from now, some nuclear plant companies go bankrupt, so be it.

Re:A near 100% renewables grid is well within reach, and wit... by Schroedingersat on Friday August 26, 2022 @07:26PM (#32613916)
Re. French nuclear saving the day:

https://www.eex.com/en/market-data/power/futures#%7B%22snipp...

Look at the quarterly tab.

And these claims that the prices can go down are contingent on serial production. 30-40 years is the time window at which significant capacity starts being made, not finishing.

What matters is Joules before 2050 not starting at 2060, and even the most optimistic projections have them costing on the order of $200-500/MWh with nuclear.

Re:A near 100% renewables grid is well within reach, and wit... by trashtester on Friday August 26, 2022 @08:27PM (#32614341)
> Re. French nuclear saving the day:

When supply cannot meet demand, prices do not represent production costs.

Building a nuclear plant takes about 5 years. In situations with sufficient sense of urgency, construction speeds can be ramped up surprisingly quickly.

From 1940 to 1944 US federal spending went up about ninefold (while GDP almost doubled as a result)

The liberty ships were the most obvious example. Initially it took 230 days to build them (in 1941), in 1943 it took 39 days.

A more modern example is the number of cars built by Tesla each year. From 2013 to 2023, the number of cars built per year will have increased by a factor of about 100x.

Similar economies of scale are available for energy plants, if we choose to. For solar panels and batteries, we're already seeing this.

If the political will was there today to vastly expand the amount of nuclear power, we would be able to produce A LOT within 10-15 years.

The same goes for renewables, of course, as long as raw materials and technologies are available.

Re:A near 100% renewables grid is well within reach, and wit... by ZeroGravitas on Friday August 26, 2022 @06:09AM (#32605393)
You appear to agree that solar and wind and batteries are the best options for most of the world even if your optimistic nuclear price point is reached.

So it's not clear what you are arguing against? Isn't that the best way to reduce dependence on fossil fuels which are a global commodity?

Re:A near 100% renewables grid is well within reach, and wit... by trashtester on Friday August 26, 2022 @07:18AM (#32605892)
Eventually, perhaps, but I see fully renewable as just slightly less sci fi than fusion or thorium.

Instead, I'm seeing countries like Germany restart their dirty, old, lignite fueled power plants (due to lack of natural gas, another, slightly cleaner, fossil fuel), because "environmentalist" organizations have been fighting against nuclear for the last 40 years or more.

Germany has TRIED to build up a lot of renewable capacity, but have hardly built up more than the electricity provided by the nuclear they shut down.

What I want is for us to SHUT DOWN all fossil fuel plants ASAP, stop using natural gas for heating and oil based fuels for most transportation.

This should and could have been started 40 years ago, if it were not for the scaremongers.

I welcome all renewable initiatives that are able to prove they can deliver stable power at a competitive price, and wish them the best of luck. I do NOT welcome the Utopia-chasers that promote renewables as part of their virtue signaling, while either being unrealistic or deceitful about motives, costs, challenges around stability, etc (both before and after investments are made).

And this is especially bad when they spread lies about the safety level of nuclear (either direct lies, or more likely when talking about "radiation" as something dangerous regardless of intensity).

I do realize that such behavior exists in all camps, but I find it especially bad when so called "environmentalists" have promoted policies that have had the net effect of NOT being able to reduce emissions nearly as much as we could have, while still causing prices to increase and ALSO maximize our dependence on Putin and various Arab dictatorial kings and princes.

And btw, while you seem to be charitable about nuclear, only arguing from a cost perspective, there are plenty of organizations out there that still place nuclear in the "dirty" camp alongside fossil fuels when arguing about strategies for the future.

So, while I'm certainly supporting most initiatives that aim to improve renewable power production, I think we (and especially Europe) should invest in a relatively large number of new, reasonably priced nuclear plants, for instance based on recent Korean designs.

Re:A near 100% renewables grid is well within reach, and wit... by Schroedingersat on Friday August 26, 2022 @08:17AM (#32606387)
NB: You're replying to two different people.

The problems with nuclear as I see them are:

Cost. These projections are very optimistic.

Corruption potential. It's pretty typical for large long term projects to 'go bankrupt' and the cleanup fund is mysteriously empty. There are also a lot of hidden externalities -- publicly funded security, infrastructure, concessions required to keep fuel producers placated. It's too centralized for believable complete accounting.

Geopolitical. Adoption of nuclear outside of UK/France/USA/China/Russia essentially tips the global power balance even further in favour of colonial powers and corps that have caused the problem in the first place and continue to export mass suffering.

Incomplete. Most of the world will never be allowed to have enrichment capabilities, and many countries will never be allowed a nuclear program at all. This means low burnup reactors, and there is not enough uranium for a complete replacement to primary energy at 3% burnup.

Consistent overpromising. Predictions for large projects seem to be consistently wrong when they're 40 years out.

Cost doesn't look great anymore when you include cleanup. Incidents will happen, especially if regulations are relaxed. Even if the rate goes down tenfold we'll still be talking on the order of one a decade, and spending a trillion on cleanup starts making other solutions look pretty great.

Re:A near 100% renewables grid is well within reach, and wit... by trashtester on Friday August 26, 2022 @11:25AM (#32608733)
> NB: You're replying to two different people.

I saw that, after writing my piece, though.

I think my main objection with your points is that I see nuclear as an alternative to fossil fuels, NOT as an alternative to renewables.

As for each point, I will start with the last: > Cost doesn't look great anymore when you include cleanup.

Actual harm caused by nuclear is miniscule when compared to fossil fuels. Chernobyl caused somewhere between 1000 and 100000 casualties, probably less than air pollution from fossil fuels cause EACH YEAR, only in Europe.

Wind and even hydro also create considerable environmental effects, so the alternative cost should not be seen as zero.

There is no evidence (at least not conclusive evidence) that exposure to radiation doses below 80-100mSv cause any health hazard, and a lot of the "cleanup" and other measures are done to prevent exposure to doses that are often below 10mSv per person, and are probably not needed.

> Corruption potential.

I live in a country with very low levels of classical corruption, luckily. I think corruption affects everything, and should be dealt with as a separate problem.

> Geopolitical. Adoption of nuclear outside of UK/France/USA/China/Russia ..

I suppose India should be added to your list. Anyway, some of the biggest deposits are in countries like Australia. Obviously, I don't want to force anyone to adopt nuclear, but it's a lot easier to find friendly suppliers of nuclear fuel than natural gas.

> Incomplete.

Same thing.

> Consistent overpromising.

40 years ago, reactors were typically built to only last 40 years. (They were also cheaper to build back then). Only newer models are designed for longer lifespans. Anyway, from my perspective, most reactors continue to deliver despite old age, if well maintained, and they don't shut down just because Putin has a temper tantrum.

If you're living in Europe, just imagine what the price of electricity would be if France's electricity depended on natural gas the same way the German does...

Re:A near 100% renewables grid is well within reach, and wit... by evancox100 on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @02:01PM (#32583303)
So you can buffer the wind/solar output for just 78 minutes? Doesn’t sound like a complete solution.

Edit: I guess per the paper it really depends on the specific details of generation/load timing. Could be workable for a certain region but not for another.

Re:A near 100% renewables grid is well within reach, and wit... by qqqwerty on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @02:20PM (#32583613)
The parent is pointing out, that if you are trying to find a solution to generate 5kw of constant power using nuclear, for the same cost you can get an absurd amount of renewable generation and storage plus a backup generator. The batteries can store 15 hours worth of energy at peak demand, you get a 10x overbuild of peak capacity in solar, plus wind, biogas and a backup generator to boot. It is highly unlikely that the system would ever fail. I would guess you could probably cut the system size in half and still have uptime in the high 9's. And the added bonus is you would have a fair bit of redundancy should any part of the system need maintenance, whereas the nuclear solution doesn't even come with a backup generator.
Re:A near 100% renewables grid is well within reach, and wit... by Schroedingersat on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @02:12PM (#32583499)
The demonstration is 5kW year round with insignificant consumption of fossil fuels everywhere with a climate about as good as Toronto or better, not having somewhere to put all the sunlight. Mid-winter in high latitude you get as little as 2hrs of sunlight/day (or 0 in the arctic, but hardly anyone lives there). If you live in the tropics, 10kW is probably fine.

Also if you feel the need to use it up, electrolyzers are cheap and hydrogen is worth money. You can also store a great deal of energy in a few tonnes of NaOH and avoid using precious winter electricity for heating.

You can also reshuffle the wind, solar and battery for your local climate, or wait a year or three for sodium batteries to halve the price.

Re:A near 100% renewables grid is well within reach, and wit... by s1artibartfast on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @02:51PM (#32584028)
I'm not all in on nuclear, but nameplate comparison is meaningless. Solar might hit the name plate for a few hours a day with suitable weather while nuclear can run 24/7 or on demand.
Re:A near 100% renewables grid is well within reach, and wit... by Schroedingersat on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @03:42PM (#32584728)
Good thing we weren't comparing nameplate then but instead comparing ability to meet baseload on a cost basis (that thing that's supposed to be most strongly in favour of nuclear) and finding the result insanely in favour of renewables

5kW nameplate nuclear is 3-4.5kW net with 10-40% of the time needing total backup and zero ability to meet higher peak demand.

The system I described needs 2.4 hours of peak sunlight spread throughout a day or 15 hours of wind in a day or 30kg of biofuel (not doable for very many days) or 30kg of imported fuel or any combination with the battery averaging 1-5(ie. you meet ~85% of load with wind/biofuel and draw ~20% of battery) days to meet the 5kW target. It also has a massive peak capacity which dwarfs the nuclear system during half of the year. You might need to tilt the panels two or three times a year in parts of Canada or similar, and maybe import a few days worth of ethanol (or any other stable hydrocarbon you can run your generator on) each year, but this is still less backup than a fission plant needs.

Couple it to an uncorrelated system or trade some solar for an electrolyzer and fuel cells and you can reduce reliance on imported fuel even more. Solar cells and batteries will also better than halve in price well before your plant is finished -- likely making it impossible to even run, let alone recoup your costs. Additionally perovskites work better with partial shade and are quite likely to hit cost parity with solar so the nameplate value can be reduced (or reliability on a still, cloudy, winter, northern morning will increase).

Re:A near 100% renewables grid is well within reach, and wit... by insane_dreamer on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @02:06PM (#32583395)
nuclear definitely needs to be in the mix to reach 100% fossil-fuel-free energy generation; not gonna happen on wind/solar/hydro alone
Re:A near 100% renewables grid is well within reach, and wit... by epistasis on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @02:32PM (#32583779)
This has been an article of religious faith, but I'm not sure it has ever been a technologically defensible opinion. Before the recent order of magnitude drops in battery prices, it may have been an economical argument, but to make that economic argument one would have to ignore the technological tech curve of solar and renewables.

And now that nuclear won't be able to compete on the economics, whereas 10 years ago we though we could still build nuclear for historical prices, people have not updated their reasoning.

Most of the models that included nuclear alongside renewables used far far lower prices for nuclear than we can actually build it for. And even then, nuclear was only selected at ~10% of generation for cost reasons, not tech reasons.

Re:A near 100% renewables grid is well within reach, and wit... by scarby2 on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @02:50PM (#32584017)
The data doesn't include SMRs and MSRs which could be extremely compelling both from a cost and time to build perspective (or they could be a dead end).

Current gen LWRs are problematic for all sorts of reasons but i wouldn't rule nuclear out of the fight just yet. Especially when you take into account china's track record of delivering nuclear plants at a competitive price.

Re:A near 100% renewables grid is well within reach, and wit... by epistasis on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @03:13PM (#32584333)
I'm reminded of Admiral Rickover's thoughts on this:

> An academic reactor or reactor plant almost always has the following basic characteristics: (1) It is simple. (2) It is small. (3) It is cheap. (4) It is light. (5) It can be built very quickly. (6) It is very flexible in purpose. (7) Very little development will be required. It will use off-the-shelf components. (8) The reactor is in the study phase. It is not being built now.

>On the other hand a practical reactor can be distinguished by the following characteristics: (1) It is being built now. (2) It is behind schedule. (3) It requires an immense amount of development on apparently trivial items. (4) It is very expensive. (5) It takes a long time to build because of its engineering development problems. (6) It is large. (7) It is heavy. (8) It is complicated.

SMRs and MSRs are in the academic stage at the moment. We don't know what they will look like at the end when they are actual products, but there are technical and practical reasons that they haven't been tried before now, so I think it's only prudent to withhold enthusiasm until we have data on their characteristics and potential.

Back in the 80s, we had PV panels in hand, and knowledge of silicon tech curves that could predict the rosy future we live in today. SMRs are a bit more shaky.

Re:A near 100% renewables grid is well within reach, and wit... by craig_s_bell on Thursday August 25, 2022 @03:47PM (#32599064)
Please note that SMR technology has advanced beyond the academic stage. After years of review, NuScale's design has been approved by the Nuclear Regulatory Commission.

Multiple sites are planning for their use, both in the United States and elsewhere: https://www.nuscalepower.com/Projects/Current-Projects/Unite...

Re:A near 100% renewables grid is well within reach, and wit... by epistasis on Thursday August 25, 2022 @10:10PM (#32602592)
Unconstructed plans are the very definition of academic.

NRC approval doesn't say anything about constructability or economics. It doesn't even say much about the operating characteristics, except that the NRC is pretty sure it meets the safety guidelines.

This is why there are these characteristics that Rickover lists, which NuScale will encounter when they finally build, but are not revealed by any planning they have done up until now:

> (1) It is being built now. (2) It is behind schedule. (3) It requires an immense amount of development on apparently trivial items. (4) It is very expensive. (5) It takes a long time to build because of its engineering development problems.

Re:A near 100% renewables grid is well within reach, and wit... by Schroedingersat on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @02:19PM (#32583596)
You're literally commenting on a thread about how 100% renewable is possible on a comment demonstrating that an individual can beat the cost effectiveness of new nuclear with 100% renewables.

The utility scale version of the digester is a gas peaker running on green ammonia possibly with a mix of long distance transmission. Everything else scales at least linearly.

Nuclear is dead. The last nail went into the coffin when green hydrogen first hit parity with delivered grey hydrogen in some regions. The case just gets worse from here. Stop shilling.