News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Acer sold only 5000 Chromebooks, yet Google still promoti... by bane on Saturday November 19, 2011 @10:50PM (#3257207)
I'm generally a fan of what Google does, but I really really don't understand what they're doing with ChromeOS and the Chromebooks.

Why one network oriented mobile operating system when you can have two? (where one has tons of applications and the web, while the other just has the web).

Why get vendors to build one dedicated tablet/netbookish type device (ref:Asus Transformer) when they can build 2 or 3 (ref:netbooks)?

Why improve netbooks, which are cheap and have decent battery life and are intended for network connectivity (while offering the benefits of local apps) when you can compete with them with similar devices with less functionality at twice the price?

On top of these obvious problems, the OS was announced very early (probably before there was any code written) and it took forever to come out, wasn't really available for people to just use on their own devices conveniently (I'd much rather install this on my old laptop and turn it into a halfway decent web oriented carry-around then buy some new fangled device at 600 bucks) and Google never successfully answered the questions around having Android and this at the same time.

Re:Acer sold only 5000 Chromebooks, yet Google still promoti... by philwelch on Sunday November 20, 2011 @12:06AM (#3257329)
Google's strategy seems to be to get people to spend more time on the web so they can view and click on Google ads.

On the desktop, this means less time in native apps and more time in web apps. So they sell netbooks that don't support native apps.

On mobile devices, they just want people to use smartphones rather than dumb phones. They don't even really give a shit whether they're Androids or iPhones, except introducing a competitor to the iPhone grows the smartphone market in total and commoditizes them, so they give away Android. And for that strategy to work, Android has to feature-match iOS, which means native apps. And since iPad, Google now has to grow the tablet market and commoditize them, and since iOS can be adapted to tablets, so must Android.

Re:Acer sold only 5000 Chromebooks, yet Google still promoti... by bane on Sunday November 20, 2011 @12:18AM (#3257341)
Google's strategy seems to be to get people to spend more time on the web so they can view and click on Google ads.

Which makes the strategy of coupling ChromeOS to specific hardware devices even more odd. Why not just offer it up to people to use? Give it away a la Ubuntu and see if people wholesale switch up? Heck, if it worked decently on old machines I might be able to get another couple years out of some of the unused computers I have lying around.

That'd get the eyeballs using those machines on the web and hopefully clicking on Google ads.

This present strategy (Chrome books) is obviously not doing it and seemed odd from the start -- and smells like mission creep to me.

Re:Acer sold only 5000 Chromebooks, yet Google still promoti... by jonknee on Sunday November 20, 2011 @12:33AM (#3257369)
> This present strategy (Chrome books) is obviously not doing it and seemed odd from the start -- and smells like mission creep to me.

That's likely due to the design decision to have verified boot. There is hardware specific to Chromium OS in those machines.

http://www.chromium.org/chromium-os/chromiumos-design-docs/v...

They don't need to be so secure, but then it's a tougher pitch to their only market--enterprise.

Re:Acer sold only 5000 Chromebooks, yet Google still promoti... by philwelch on Sunday November 20, 2011 @12:30AM (#3257365)
> Why not just offer it up to people to use?

The kind of people who install different OS's on computers they already own are more likely to actually need to use native apps and more likely to spend lots of time on the internet anyway. ChromeOS is better targeted at a lower end of the market.

Re:Acer sold only 5000 Chromebooks, yet Google still promoti... by bane on Sunday November 20, 2011 @01:08AM (#3257428)
ChromeOS is better targeted at a lower end of the market.

Which I agree with. It's too bad that $500-600 isn't the lower end of the market anymore. I can get a usable notebook for <$300 these days. To really make a case, they need to hit the $200-$300 segment for it to make any kind of sense.

At $600 bucks I can get an actually fairly decent Windows 7 laptop.

It just comes off as "weird" to me.

Re:Acer sold only 5000 Chromebooks, yet Google still promoti... by ansible on Sunday November 20, 2011 @08:38AM (#3258062)
> At $600 bucks I can get an actually fairly decent Windows 7 laptop.

Heh, I did just that yesterday. $600 (no tax or shipping) got me a mid-range quad-core which can be used for casual gaming too.

Re:Acer sold only 5000 Chromebooks, yet Google still promoti... by dextorious on Sunday November 20, 2011 @04:06AM (#3257679)
"Google's strategy seems to be to get people to spend more time on the web so they can view and click on Google ads."

Only this is an idiotic long term strategy, if Google was to go even more full speed ahead to achieve this. Getting people to spend more time on the web takes a lot more money that can be generated per person via Google ads. Especially when they can spend that time on Facebook or any other Google competitor.

Google, for example, looses tons of money on Android just to "secure" their place among mobile platforms. This will not go well.

Re:Acer sold only 5000 Chromebooks, yet Google still promoti... by snotrockets on Sunday November 20, 2011 @04:11PM (#3259032)
Re:Acer sold only 5000 Chromebooks, yet Google still promoti... by jonknee on Sunday November 20, 2011 @12:29AM (#3257363)
The article mentioned the enterprise segment and that's not surprising. I would love nothing more than to hand a Chromebook to the business customers I deal with. It keeps up to date, doesn't break and they can't install stuff on it. There goes about 95% of problems.

The market they are going after isn't small, but it also it's quick to adopting new solutions (Windows XP is still common, it came out in 2001...).