News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Racism and Meritocracy by raganwald on Saturday November 19, 2011 @03:16PM (#3256114)
I read an artcile suggesting that people believe certain things about race and bias but that the evidence is not there to support their beliefs. I read an artcile that suggests that people construct explanations to fit their world view. I'm merely pointing out that off-hand comments like this exactly fit the behaviour described in the article: Constructing explanations to fit a pre-existing set of beliefs.

I have a great deal of personal intest in the subject of race and bias, and I assure you that in twelve seconds of Googling, I will find enough conflicting evidence and explanations to suggest that the causes for bias are complex.

If I looked at a mountain of conflicting evidence with a predetermined belief, I'm sure I could find validation for whatever I already believed. So, I don't doubt for a moment that if you already agree with these statements, twelve seconds with Google will confirm our suspicions, just as I am sure that someone who vehemently disagrees with these statements will also find confirmation of their disagreement with twelve seconds of Googling.

UPDATE: To be clear, I'm not saying that Max is wrong: I don't live in the US, much less in SV. How should I know what American women and minorities are thinking? But what I am saying is that statements like this in a forum like this suggest not only that the speaker has preconceived beliefs about this, but that he also expects evryone else to share those beliefs.

Re:Racism and Meritocracy by guard-of-terra on Saturday November 19, 2011 @03:24PM (#3256138)
Can you provide us with the model of what you think is happening?

Because "I think that something bad is happening but I don't know what" does not lead to a constructive discussion at all.

Re:Racism and Meritocracy by _pius on Saturday November 19, 2011 @03:28PM (#3256145)
To the contrary, I think it is constructive to question sweeping and inflammatory claims backed up by little more than adverbs.
Re:Racism and Meritocracy by guard-of-terra on Saturday November 19, 2011 @03:31PM (#3256154)
Sorry, but while there is only one model of what's happening it would remain both questionable AND popular.

To make it move you have to provide a new one.