Re:Is There an HN for Women?
by alldayeveryday on Monday August 22, 2022 @09:09AM
(#32550806)
> Say women in tech want a male-free space? Well fine.
> The issue is, what then about "white men in tech"? Do they get to have a group to themselves, to discuss issues from [...]
An interesting observation that white men having their own space is an "issue" whereas any other collective is not an issue.
Re:Is There an HN for Women?
by rich_sasha on Monday August 22, 2022 @10:25AM
(#32551844)
As i say, neither bothers me too much. But I'd imagine various groups that want their own space would not like their complement making a space just for themselves, and not letting them in.
GP's reasoning is by modus tollens.
Re:Is There an HN for Women?
by alldayeveryday on Monday August 22, 2022 @10:16AM
(#32551714)
Concerning this topic I commonly see the logic:
If P, then Q. Not Q. But still, P.
The issue is, what then about "white men in tech"? Do they get to have a group to themselves, to discuss issues from, dunno, "dealing with tech Feminazis", or whatever white men in tech struggle with? What about white supremacists in tech? Elite SEs against influx of cheap junior labour?
I'm personally not a member of any such "selective" groups and for these reasons feel a bit ambivalent about them.
But as i say, go ahead as far as I'm concerned...