News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Consensus not censorship by peyton on Sunday August 21, 2022 @01:21PM (#32542290)
I see you’re coming from a good place. I just think taking away voice amplifiers (smashing the printing press, so to speak) hasn’t turned out well in the past, and I don’t see a strong enough reason to start doing that now.
Re:Consensus not censorship by epgui on Sunday August 21, 2022 @01:24PM (#32542323)
I think there's a very clear line we can draw between different categories of smashing the printing press:

- "banning books because they criticize the government"

- "banning books because they have immoral content"

And on the other hand:

- "shutting down a viral video with advice dangerous to individuals, where protecting the public from direct physical harm is the goal"

I don't know of any instances in History where we looked back at the latter in disapproval.

Re:Consensus not censorship by peyton on Sunday August 21, 2022 @01:51PM (#32542602)
What we look back in disapproval upon is empowering a group to do the silencing. I think because those who do the silencing usually end up silencing their own critics.
Re:Consensus not censorship by epgui on Sunday August 21, 2022 @02:05PM (#32542754)
I don't think this is always the case, and that's exactly my point.

> "those who do the silencing usually end up silencing their own critics"

I'm not even sure that this usually happens. It is certainly the case that when that happens, it is very memorable. But that's probably just a "selective attention bias" applied to History, that is, because the other cases are unremarkable.

Re:Consensus not censorship by peyton on Sunday August 21, 2022 @02:20PM (#32542903)
I see your point, and still I don’t think it’s a good idea. We don’t give power like that to expertise for the same reason the commander-in-chief of the armed forces is a civilian.
Re:Consensus not censorship by epgui on Sunday August 21, 2022 @02:24PM (#32542947)
We do give this power very narrowly and very successfully to many individuals in their official capacity, in different contexts. Judges, professors, administrative committees, employers in certain situations, heck, at the moment, any company with a platform can apply this power essentially arbitrarily and at will (which I'd argue is not great).
Re:Consensus not censorship by raxxorraxor on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @09:24AM (#32564562)
If you take the ability to see the content away from me I trust you to evaluate the content exactly as much as you trust me to do so. How do you solve that conundrum?
Re:Consensus not censorship by astrobe_ on Sunday August 21, 2022 @06:00PM (#32544893)
To protect is always the initial goal, and directly dangerous videos are the low hanging fruits.

I'd say "viral videos" are too recent to be part of History yet, but shutting down a dangerous viral video is not very far from "banning immoral content", which is not very far itself from "banning hate speech".

It's not that easy to draw a line because it is a continuum.

Consensus and censorship is what many countries do: People vote for MPs, MPs vote laws against hate speech, pornography, etc. Or at least how it's supposed to work on the paper.

The same way, we could decide for laws against media that propagates misinformation - and a judge would decide. We could do that. The tools are on the workbench, why we can't use them is another problem.

Re:Consensus not censorship by yongjik on Sunday August 21, 2022 @02:14PM (#32542843)
On the other hand, judging from the past 5-6 years, freely giving out voice amplifiers (Facebook and targeted ads, anyone?) clearly didn't turn out well either, so the optimum is probably somewhere in the middle.
Re:Consensus not censorship by peyton on Sunday August 21, 2022 @02:25PM (#32542964)
I think a workable solution can be found. I don’t know if that’s necessarily a middle ground between amplification and censorship; feels like that could be the “middle ground” fallacy. We’ve solved problems like this in the past.
Re:Consensus not censorship by yongjik on Sunday August 21, 2022 @03:07PM (#32543359)
I don't think we've solved these problems in the past. We simply didn't have such problems at the scale we have now.
Re:Consensus not censorship by epgui on Sunday August 21, 2022 @02:42PM (#32543155)
The middle ground fallacy does not apply here. It only applies when one of the two things being considered is incorrect.
Re:Consensus not censorship by peyton on Sunday August 21, 2022 @03:00PM (#32543311)
You already said amplification was incorrect. I think you’re not willing to budge on censoring things you know to be incorrect and dangerous, so ironically we won’t be able to find middle ground. That’s okay.
Re:Consensus not censorship by epgui on Sunday August 21, 2022 @03:13PM (#32543413)
No, "amplification" is not an all-or-nothing phenomenon. What I said is that there should be limits to amplification. Ruling out an extreme does not rule out the middle ground.

The way this works is that there are some questions that have clear answers. For example, anthropogenic climate change (or to be more precise, the idea that "Most of the warming of Earth’s average global temperature over the second half of the 20th century has been caused by human activities."). The middle ground fallacy is what you call it when you put up two people on TV, one who is an expert on climate change, and another who is just a contrarian, and where you don't frame it exactly as it is: one is wrong and the other is right.

That's not the same thing as this conversation we're having.

Re:Consensus not censorship by kastagg on Sunday August 21, 2022 @01:51PM (#32542610)
In this metaphor, are the printing presses private property?