Re:“Quantum-Safe” Crypto Hacked by 10-Year-Old PC
by Zamicol on Friday August 19, 2022 @05:29PM
(#32526163)
All the works I've read of Schneier have given me the impression of the above definition, "support multiple cryptographic primitives and do not be overly coupled to a single primitive."
Serendipitously, I just tweeted about this 11 days ago: https://twitter.com/CyphrMe/status/1556660870901403648
"The moral is the need for cryptographic agility. It’s not enough to implement a single standard; it’s vital that our systems be able to easily swap in new algorithms when required."
Do you have a link to something that in your mind represents what Schneier is talking about?
Re:“Quantum-Safe” Crypto Hacked by 10-Year-Old PC
by tptacek on Friday August 19, 2022 @05:48PM
(#32526370)
A modern cryptosystem wouldn't be designed to swap in new algorithms; it would pick a single set of algorithms and constructions, and version the whole system. Which is how WireGuard works: you can't run AES WireGuard, or WireGuard with the standard P-curves.
If you want to say "minimalist agility is good and you're just saying maximalist agility is bad", that's fine, we're just bickering about terms. But that's pretty obviously not what Schneier is talking about.