This is because their derivatives unit was acquired, previously LedgerX, which I've used happily for 2 years. They're professionals, and not sketchy. It's really unfortunate that the antics and sketchiness of the parent might affect the perfectly legitimate and rule-following child company, and all of their customers like myself.
Wondering if I should close my positions, sigh.
edit: Wow, what a deceptive clickbait title! Should read "FDIC tells FTX US to delete a tweet".
(I've restructured this comment removing only a tangential illustration of shareholders liability, adding only to make my meaning clear from the beginning)
Prior to which you argue that the subsidiary is regulated as a commodities trading house. If so, CFTC is likely to promptly suspend them after digesting this FDIC enforcement action.
You appeal to the reputation implied of a known historical entity and or management and dismiss the enforcement action against the combined post acquisition entity as trivia. This is a circular conflagration as disingenuous as the offending misrepresentation of Federal guarantees. I'm suspicious of what connection you may have to this company and thinking your comments may be construed as flagrant obstruction the enforcement of Federal law through persistence with the estopped activities. If you are associated in any way but spoke independently, I think this one is really worth sitting out. For a start FDIC account protection is provided to individuals via FDIC insured banks and can't be parlayed by any broker. FDX referring to individual and or separate insured deposits I'm expecting to give rise to charges of interstate fraud at least. The targets of current enforcement are almost certainly intended to establish case law to enable sweeping enforcement and punishment I think I'm going to say is expected this time, through lower courts.
(Continues unchanged)
The usual resulting status of a any company acquired is "wholly controlled subsidiary" , and bar special classes of shares outstanding accounts and corporate governance arising from the parent holding majority voting rights prevails over any surviving minority shareholders or board member votes. It's theoretically possible for a acquirer to overlook the perfunctory resignation of the board and end up having to use company law and call for a EGM to vote on the termination of incumbent recalcitrant directors, but hardly likely anyone in the farthest reaches of M&A would have so little oversight of catastrophic professional liability.
In plain English there's no separation nor distinction between a subsidiary and its parent.
You could invent intricate arms length contrivances and claim independent operations, but unless each corporate entity has clearly independent capital structure, claims of independence are liable to be interpreted as fraudulent in English or judicial evaluation. Multinationals using offshore treasury vehicles use companies limited by guarantee and partnerships for avoidance of this category of responsibility.
The FDIC and other comments make it easier to see that the problem is widespread. Otherwise the FDIC wouldn't need so much boilerplate putting the onus on the respondent to deliver complete record of all misleading and unlawful communication.
Edited: replaced "guaranteed by share capital" with "limited by guarantee".
Your exacting precision and care with words lies in stark contrast to my comment's lack thereof, is the mark of someone who knows what they're talking about, and is probably a lawyer with domain specific knowledge. :)
Though I doubt anyone will see this, to be clear, the vast majority of my "communicative intent" was to express:
* My explanation for WHY and HOW it came to be that the derivatives unit, FTX US Derivatives (aka LedgerX), has the proper licenses and is probably run with a different management philosophy than the parent. (that explanation being: "because they were acquired, not part of the original parent group of FTX people")
* My displeasure with what I think is a quite misleading and exaggerated "clickbait" title.
My feeling that it would be a sad state of affairs if the bad (and possibly illegal!) behavior of the parent company were to adversely affect the rule-following child and the rule-following customers was a minor point, though one I still stand by. I am curious if you agree that it wound be unfortunate?
Consumers gripe over unfortunate changes by and in management of their preferred vendors all the time, while being fully aware of the legal reality. :) I could have just as well been complaining about a great restaurant or coffee shop which was acquired. Either way, it was a minor point.
I'm aware that post-acquisition, even though it's not unusual for an acquired and independent business unit to continue operating just as they always had, in the eyes of the law any distinction between acquiring and acquired company is dissolved. As you correctly state "there's no separation nor distinction between a subsidiary and its parent". I know this, but that doesn't mean it's not "unfortunate".
> This is a circular conflagration as disingenuous as the offending misrepresentation...
No. You are incorrect. Nothing I said is disingenuous.
> I'm suspicious of what connection you may have to this company...
LIKEWISE!! :)
(I'm just a customer, though I'm flattered.)
And yes, you are correct that "FTX US Derivatives is a digital currency futures and options exchange and clearinghouse regulated by the US Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC)".
Though I have yet to see any change in their operation -- CFTC has not "promptly suspended them" -- I do wonder if anything will happen.
Doordash, Postmates and Uber have proven this works when their business was under fire through AB5 legislation they spent hundreds of millions on a state proposition to block it
He's doing it. He's become a huge political contributor. He's pushing something called the "Responsible Financial Innovation Act".[2] The proponents of this want to remove the SEC's authority over crypto things that look like securities, and be regulated by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, which doesn't look that hard at offerings. From the bill text:
"Notwithstanding any other provision of law, if an issuer issues a security through an arrangement or scheme that constitutes an investment contract, ... and is in compliance with the periodic disclosure requirements under subsection (c), an ancillary asset provided directly or indirectly by the issuer shall be presumed ... to be a commodity"
So far, the bill hasn't gotten beyond introduction. There's considerable opposition. Since the massive collapse in crypto markets, and bankrupcies all over the place, it's less likely to go anywhere.
However, the political pressure has been successful in discouraging the SEC from bringing the hammer down on everything in crypto that looks like an unregistered security. They've been going after about two blatant scams a month. But the SEC hasn't been telling the entire industry, file an S-1 signed under penalty of perjury and get SEC approval, like every stock offering. (It's not that the paperwork is the problem. It's that lying on the paperwork is a felony.)
U.S. securities regulation uses something called the "Howey test" to determine if something is a security. (The name comes from a 1946 case where someone got creative and tried to securitize orange-picking rights in Florida.) The Howey test requires all four of the following:
1. Money is invested. ("Money" means anything of value here.)
2. There is an expected profit ("To the moon!")
3. The money investment is a common enterprise.
4. Profit comes from the third-party or promoter’s efforts.
Many crypto schemes have been devised to get around this. #1 was back around 2015-2017, when claims were made that crypto coins were not "money". That's been settled; they're assets for tax and regulatory purposes. #2, the "expected profit" thing usually isn't hard to prove. Non-fungible tokens are an attempt to get around #3 by claiming that each NFT is its own collectable, so there is no common enterprise. But the marketing around NFTs ("floor price", "collections") tend to make that an iffy defense. Attempts to get around #4 involve turning control, or the illusion of it, over to a DAO, so the DAO, owned by the investors, takes the heat, while their subcontractor, the promoter, rakes in money. I don't think that one has been litigated yet.
Once you understand this, how crypto schemes are organized starts to make sense. The crypto industry lost on #1. #3 is the reason ICOs are dead and NFTs are in. #4 is the motivator behind DAOs.
[1] https://theintercept.com/2022/08/05/crypto-lobby-ftx-pacs-sa...
[2] https://www.congress.gov/bill/117th-congress/senate-bill/435...
As well as Apple, Google, Microsoft, Amazon, Facebook, Samsung, and the list goes on with their bribery in the US.
But thank you for confirming that the tech bros here are no different to the crypto bros also lobbying congress.
If you’re referring to the LA and nearby ports being clogged, my understanding is that there was a massive rise in demand as restrictions (from COVID) were lifted, and they happened to coincide with the holiday season. Workers (and truckers), also at that time, realized they deserve better working conditions and decided to stop working, leading to an inability to move containers. That’s not AB5’s fault.
Before AB5, a carrier company could hire an owner-operator to do some work without them being employees (eg. to handle excess work that their employees could not), but now they cannot, so those carriers are not sending any more business to owner-operators.
The options for owner-operators, who paid a large sum to acquire their truck, are to move out of California, become employees (owner-operators likely don't want that, hence them acquiring their own truck), or stop driving altogether.
Since California is a major port of entry for goods in the USA, having fewer truckers to move those goods leads to logistical issues.
Don't be so prickly.
Coinbase is positioned well for a CEX, but not...well.
At one point, people thought it was legit enough to treat cryptocurrencies in the same way one might treat collectible trading cards.
Are they not? Sure, they're not FDIC insured, but it's pretty clear from the press release that the insurance is just the company itself promising to pay depositors if there are unexpected losses. Obviously if the losses exceed whatever has in the bank, the insurance won't be able to cover everything.
The trouble with FTX is that they are a pretend bank and brokerage. They offer services that look like banking and brokerage, but the backup isn't there. They're not regulated as a bank or a broker, and they don't have the insurance of a bank or a broker.
From their site:
* "FTX US is a US licensed cryptocurrency exchange that welcomes American users."
* "The safe and easy way to get into crypto."
* "We are US based and regulated"
* "Don't be like Larry".
There is a concerted effort to create an illusion of legitimacy.
Even in their disclosures[2], you can see them trying to create the illusion that they're regulated as a financial institution. Their derivatives unit, FTX US Derivatives, does have some of the licenses of a commodity exchange. The main company, "West Realm Shire Services" (remember Magic, the Gathering Online Exchange?) just has money transmitter licenses. Not in NY or CA, interestingly. They don't have a banking license from a state. Or a New York State BitLicense. Or a brokerage license from the SEC.[3] Or an exchange license from the SEC. Or Security Investors Protection Corporation insurance. Or Financial Industry Regulatory Authority regulation.
[1] https://newsoutlet.ai/blockchain/celsius-ceo-alex-mashinsky-...
[2] https://ftx.us/legal/regulations-licenses
[3] https://www.sec.gov/reportspubs/investor-publications/divisi...