Re:I have complicated feelings about TDD
by EddySchauHai on Thursday August 18, 2022 @04:42PM
(#32514629)
> Also with TDD often it will be centered in quantity of tests and not so much quality.
100%. Metrics of quality are really really hard to define in a way that are both productive and not gamified by engineers.
> What I find is much much better approach is what I call "detached test development" (DTD)
I'm a test engineer and some companies do 'embed' an SDET like the way you mention within a team - it's not quite that clear cut, they can discuss, but it's still one person implementing and another testing.
I'm always happy to see people with thoughts on testing as a core part of good engineering rather than an afterthought/annoyance :)
100%. Metrics of quality are really really hard to define in a way that are both productive and not gamified by engineers.
> What I find is much much better approach is what I call "detached test development" (DTD)
I'm a test engineer and some companies do 'embed' an SDET like the way you mention within a team - it's not quite that clear cut, they can discuss, but it's still one person implementing and another testing.
I'm always happy to see people with thoughts on testing as a core part of good engineering rather than an afterthought/annoyance :)