Re:Carmack rewriting Doom 3 source code to dodge legal issues
by krig on Friday November 18, 2011 @06:26AM
(#3251392)
Triviality is supposed to be a test case for the validity of a patent. I think you can make a reasonable argument that if the first few users of a technology all independently invent a technique, that technique should be considered trivial in the context of that technology.
I don't think it's necessary to deify Carmack, either. He is an extraordinary programmer, but he is not super-human.
Re:Carmack rewriting Doom 3 source code to dodge legal issues
by nailer on Friday November 18, 2011 @06:49AM
(#3251432)
Isn't the test 'an engineer sufficiently skilled in the art' ?
Carmack would qualify as 'an engineer sufficiently skilled in the art'. That he's one of the most skilled wouldn't be relevant.
Software patents are ridiculous, but not because (or only if) they're trivial.