Re:Carmack rewriting Doom 3 source code to dodge legal issues
by MatthewPhillips on Thursday November 17, 2011 @10:49PM
(#3250518)
So this patent covers an implement of Foo that is 6 lines of code? How is that possible?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Carmack rewriting Doom 3 source code to dodge legal issues
by grannyg00se on Friday November 18, 2011 @12:33AM
(#3250718)
I'm sure six lines of Carmack code can contain a solution that is novel, useful, and non-obvious.
Re:Carmack rewriting Doom 3 source code to dodge legal issues
by greyfade on Friday November 18, 2011 @04:19PM
(#3253463)
It's neither novel nor non-obvious. It's a minor variation on a well-known and oft-used algorithm. Carmack himself said as much when he started talking about the algorithm.
Re:Carmack rewriting Doom 3 source code to dodge legal issues
by grannyg00se on Saturday November 19, 2011 @03:15PM
(#3256110)
And that's where I have a problem with software patents in particular. I'm not in the camps that believe nothing should be patentable, or that some ideas should be patentable - but not software. I'm okay with software patents as a concept (for now). However, with software patents it seems there is a higher than average likelihood that an obvious and trivial patent will be granted. You'll have patents for things like: "a method to confirm a user action whereby a dialog window is presented to the user with several buttons including but not limited to Yes and No." This is just an example but I've seen similar patents granted.
Re:Carmack rewriting Doom 3 source code to dodge legal issues
by greyfade on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @04:02PM
(#3271711)
There is also an non-insignificant number of patents that expressly cover an algorithm that would have been found in most computer science textbooks - verbatim - since the '70s. One notable example is the Quicksort algorithm (US 5,175,857). Another is arithmetic coding (known since at least 1976), which has been patented no less than 31 times.
If basic information theory can be patented, there's a problem.
Re:Carmack rewriting Doom 3 source code to dodge legal issues
by jgh on Thursday November 17, 2011 @11:21PM
(#3250591)
Technically if he wants to do depth-pass instead of depth-fail, he has to change two or three lines of code. He probably added a workaround for the depth-pass near clipping plane errors.
Re:Carmack rewriting Doom 3 source code to dodge legal issues
by Arelius on Friday November 18, 2011 @04:19AM
(#3251172)
Depth-fail is chosen due to working in the Camera-in-shadow-volume case, not the near clipping plane errors. This is the workaround he needs to solve for considering the Doom3 usage case.
Re:Carmack rewriting Doom 3 source code to dodge legal issues
by sliverstorm on Friday November 18, 2011 @12:54AM
(#3250750)
Just thank the gods they haven't (yet) figured out how to patent the idea of "whitespace" and "comments".