News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Carmack rewriting Doom 3 source code to dodge legal issues by 1010011010 on Thursday November 17, 2011 @09:27PM (#3250302)
Software patents are monopolies on ideas, which is a stupid idea.
Re:Carmack rewriting Doom 3 source code to dodge legal issues by grannyg00se on Friday November 18, 2011 @12:36AM (#3250728)
All patents are monopolies on ideas. How is a software patent any different?
Re:Carmack rewriting Doom 3 source code to dodge legal issues by burgerbrain on Friday November 18, 2011 @12:40AM (#3250731)
Software is math, and until a few years ago, math was generally held to be unpatentable.
Re:Carmack rewriting Doom 3 source code to dodge legal issues by fragsworth on Friday November 18, 2011 @02:52AM (#3251005)
Every idea is math, even ideas for physical devices, as long as it is well-defined. If it's not well-defined, then it's ambiguous, and probably shouldn't be patented.
Re:Carmack rewriting Doom 3 source code to dodge legal issues by burgerbrain on Friday November 18, 2011 @02:57AM (#3251015)
Physical devices can be modeled with math, they are not however mathematics itself.

"Programming languages" are in reality nothing more than fancy mathematical notations. Conversion to more traditional notations, such as lambda calculus, is so trivial that any computer science undergrad can do it.

To put it bluntly, algorithms are no less math than the Pythagorean Theorem.

Re:Carmack rewriting Doom 3 source code to dodge legal issues by Dn_Ab on Friday November 18, 2011 @09:34AM (#3251816)
I would suggest a clearer example to be long division or euclid's method. Or that software is like stating the Pythagorean theorem and then proving it constructively. This way the process of what goes on when writing code is better captured in how it relates to math.
Re:Carmack rewriting Doom 3 source code to dodge legal issues by burgerbrain on Friday November 18, 2011 @12:04PM (#3252402)
Great point, thanks.
Re:Carmack rewriting Doom 3 source code to dodge legal issues by DanBC on Friday November 18, 2011 @02:12AM (#3250923)
Bizarre then that cryptography has a bunch of patents.
Re:Carmack rewriting Doom 3 source code to dodge legal issues by burgerbrain on Friday November 18, 2011 @02:16AM (#3250937)
I very much agree.
Re:Carmack rewriting Doom 3 source code to dodge legal issues by robotresearcher on Friday November 18, 2011 @03:03AM (#3251027)
| Software is math

I strongly disagree. Consider an event-driven presentation and interface layer over a database backend: a very common bit of software. You can't even explain that meaningfully in terms of math, let alone say it is math.

Some software has good math-based explanations, but lots of it doesn't. Saying software is math is rather like saying it's all ones and zeros. True in a weak sense, but it doesn't capture much that is meaningful. Often, a piece of software is better understood as a machine, which is a traditional domain of patents.

edit: I dislike software patents because they are often granted on stupid things in practice. This is probably due to abuse of the system by applicants, which is a response to the lack of expertise and bad previous judgement by the patent office, which seems to invite such abuse.

edit 2: the software patent situation is very hard to change now, since Big Software lobbies very hard to prevent that.

But software isn't math.

Re:Carmack rewriting Doom 3 source code to dodge legal issues by lloeki on Friday November 18, 2011 @03:39AM (#3251098)
Whether you want it or not, software is math[0][1]. It has nothing to do with it being "ones and zeroes" and everything to do with the work of Turing.

> You can't even explain that meaningfully in terms of math

Oh yes you can. You just lack the tools and understanding for it, and it can get very complex, very quickly, but it can be done, as the Church-Turing thesis (recursion, lambda-calculus, and Turing machines are equivalent) is mathematically proven. And people do actually use that to formally prove correctness of software[2].

[0] http://www.groklaw.net/article.php?story=20110908075658894

[1] http://www.groklaw.net/articlebasic.php?story=20111005102810...

[2] http://www.theengineer.co.uk/news/safer-software/312631.arti...

Re:Carmack rewriting Doom 3 source code to dodge legal issues by robotresearcher on Monday November 21, 2011 @02:20AM (#3260323)
> > You can't even explain that meaningfully in terms of math > Oh yes you can.

No, you can't. Proving the correctness of a word processor has almost nothing to do with the design of its functionality. What should a word processor do? The answer to that question is not math. Does this piece of code do what this written specification says it should do? The answer to that question can be produced by math. Software is at least both of these things. It certainly is not math alone.

> You just lack the tools and understanding for it, and it can get very complex, very quickly

That's an ad hominen in front of an irrelevant statement. The Church-Turing thesis is indeed proven. A simple statement of that thesis goes: "Everything algorithmically computable is computable by a Turing machine. Some things are not thus computable." This idea along its proof, is one of the finest human achievements of the twentieth century. But it sure doesn't tell you how to write a word processor. It tells you that the word processor you wrote could be run on any of a family of equivalent machines, and that it can't compute certain things. That's deep and lovely indeed. Since that proof was created, we knew that Visicalc, Word, TeX and Bit Torrent existed in the space of possible programs, and by implication we knew a lot about their properties. Somebody still had to design and write the fuckers, and they were not doing math when they did so. They were engineering software.

Another completely different angle: If you admit that "The Mythical Man Month" was any kind of contribution to software, can you explain its contribution to mathematics?

> You just lack the tools and understanding for it, and it can get very complex

I think I'll put this on a t-shirt. Thanks.

Re:Carmack rewriting Doom 3 source code to dodge legal issues by bnegreve on Friday November 18, 2011 @07:29AM (#3251510)
Software is not math. Math and software are two different things. It is true that most programs are a solution to a problem that can be formalized with math. However all math is not software and software deals with a lot of issues informally.

Computer science is math, maybe.

Re:Carmack rewriting Doom 3 source code to dodge legal issues by outworlder on Friday November 18, 2011 @01:00PM (#3252639)
Back to the university, will you? You still have a lot to learn.
Re:Carmack rewriting Doom 3 source code to dodge legal issues by bnegreve on Saturday November 26, 2011 @03:35AM (#3279431)
I honestly don't understand, software and math are obviously two different things. What should I learn about this ?
Re:Carmack rewriting Doom 3 source code to dodge legal issues by robotresearcher on Tuesday November 29, 2011 @11:55PM (#3293789)
I'm with you. I'm a tenured CS professor. I didn't want to argue from authority with those above, but in case it makes you feel better, they're wrong. Software is not math. Let's all go learn more about both things.
Re:Carmack rewriting Doom 3 source code to dodge legal issues by brain5ide on Friday November 18, 2011 @09:56AM (#3251895)
As Gerald Jay Sussman would say - computing is alchemy.