News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Quantum theorem shakes foundations by mindstab on Thursday November 17, 2011 @08:03PM (#3250024)
So this is not a new idea, it's been around for decades, and just fallen in and out of vogue. And now they present an [their] opinion piece on the topic.

I hardly think "shakes foundations" in the HN title and more of the same hyperbole in the article is warranted

Re:Quantum theorem shakes foundations by gammarator on Thursday November 17, 2011 @08:21PM (#3250078)
They've found a theorem that can subject the physical reality of the wavefunction to experimental tests. That's new, and it means this potentially won't be a matter of opinion any longer.

"Shakes foundations" is the title of the Nature summary, and it reflects the enthusiasm of the distinguished theoretical physicists quoted in the article.

Re:Quantum theorem shakes foundations by robinhouston on Thursday November 17, 2011 @08:24PM (#3250085)
This article is about a new theorem that was uploaded to the preprint server earlier this week[1], and the article quotes several quantum theorists who describe this new result as important (or even ‘seismic’). On what basis do you think it’s been around for decades?

1. http://arxiv.org/abs/1111.3328

Re:Quantum theorem shakes foundations by Jach on Thursday November 17, 2011 @08:46PM (#3250162)
The actual formal theorem is new and great, but the general battle of asserting the wave function's existence vs. non-existence (whatever either are supposed to mean) vs. saying "I don't know tell me more about the wavefunction and its experimental predictions working/failing" has been around for quite some time. Here's a nice write-up of the ridiculousness of someone definitively saying "I don't know why this works and therefore it doesn't exist!" http://lesswrong.com/lw/q5/quantum_nonrealism/
Re:Quantum theorem shakes foundations by Dn_Ab on Thursday November 17, 2011 @08:51PM (#3250177)
I believe mindstab is talking about debates as to whether a quantum wavefunction posses any objective reality. That is an old argument. For example Everett's Many World Interpretation from the 1950's posits a real universal wave function. It is also deterministic.

The one this paper purports to disprove are the ones which say wave functions are not real but a probability distribution representing your lack of knowledge of the total system state and collapse from measurement is not so different from choosing to condition on the probability distribution. I am sympathetic with the view of quantum mechanics as a bayesian complex probability theory and so will wait till more knowledgeable people critic the paper.