Re:Marc Andreessen slams new multi-family affordable housing
by metadat on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @08:03PM
(#32490691)
If it were really about money, you'd be correct. It's really about control, though.
The whole point of Atherton is privacy- the property owners don't want other living human beings within earshot.
Re:Marc Andreessen slams new multi-family affordable housing
by amluto on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @08:09PM
(#32490723)
…which one can achieve fairly well by owning a huge piece of land and building in the middle of it.
In any case, this may be what Andreesen is thinking, but it’s not what he wrote.
Re:Marc Andreessen slams new multi-family affordable housing
by ac29 on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @09:28PM
(#32491198)
> Houses in Atherton, supposed home of very expensive homes, seem to sell for around $10M per acre of lot. (Yes, Atherton is so fancy that it uses different units in Zillow!). That’s about $230 per sq ft of land.
It should be noted that the zoning rules in Atherton require a minimum lot size of 1 Acre per home. Thinking of it in terms of square feet lets you compare it to nearby towns somewhat, but misses that building say two houses per acre (1/2 acre lots) is illegal there.
Re:Marc Andreessen slams new multi-family affordable housing
by amluto on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @11:25PM
(#32491980)
Computing land value per square foot isn’t missing something — this is the whole point. Atherton has a land use restriction that depresses property values.
(Under SB9, one can likely split a 1 acre lot once. I imagine that Atherton would try to block such a split.)
But let’s try actual, if low quality, numbers:
Houses near Atherton, in Menlo Park, seem to sell for around $500k-$1M per 1000 sq ft of lot size. That’s $500 - $1000 per sq ft lot.
Houses in Atherton, supposed home of very expensive homes, seem to sell for around $10M per acre of lot. (Yes, Atherton is so fancy that it uses different units in Zillow!). That’s about $230 per sq ft of land.
In other words, Menlo Park (not exactly a paragon of high density and unrestricted land use) has 2x-4x the land value per unit area of Atherton.
So those NIMBYs who actually want to extract dollar value from their property should support less restrictive land use!
edit: of course this is the value of random houses plus their lots. I expect the effect would be more pronounced if the houses were removed — those Atherton houses tend to be quite fancy.