News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A little exercise each day improves muscles more than one... by raverbashing on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @03:04AM (#32479992)
Humm this sounds too much like "one weird trick" and I would not be surprised if the researchers fumbled this a bit

For one, doing 30 reps in the same day (with no details about if/how this was split into sets) is different than 6 reps in the same day (in terms of weight/intensity)

This is TFA https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/sms.14220

Re:A little exercise each day improves muscles more than one... by davisoneee on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @03:31AM (#32480175)
You can follow the link to the actual journal article to get details, and then criticise based on information.

The protocol was 1 session of 5x6 reps (1d5s6r), versus 5 sessions of 1x6 (5d1s6r), with control 1d1s6r.

Re:A little exercise each day improves muscles more than one... by thinkcontext on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @10:06AM (#32482907)
Plenty of workout routines have days per week devoted to focusing on particular muscle groups ("leg day" etc), the study seems aimed at looking at their effectiveness.

Its a study where they controlled variables to learn how the body responds to different types of stimulus, not a workout plan. It can inform the design of a workout plan but someone just naievely adopting this study design is

Re:A little exercise each day improves muscles more than one... by raverbashing on Wednesday August 17, 2022 @05:02AM (#32493952)
Yes, it is possible that the study helps in that sense (and yes, I'm skeptical of "leg day" workouts), I feel it is more productive to work out a muscle at least 2x week
Re:A little exercise each day improves muscles more than one... by CannisterFlux on Tuesday August 16, 2022 @03:14AM (#32480055)
Yeah, it seems fishy. If 6 reps of something is difficult enough to do such that it has in impact on muscle growth, I can't see how they could manage 30 reps of the same thing. I wonder if the 6 reps 5 days people were untrained, while the 1 set of 30 people could manage it because they were trained enough so that it was possible (and therefore too easy)? Or maybe the 1 set of 30 was with a lighter weight to make it possible?