Re:Edward O. Wilson: Marx was right, he had the wrong species
by nazgulnarsil on Monday October 06, 2008 @05:59AM
(#324743)
you're right. marxism is intertwined with the idea of a class struggle throughout history. I would say the free market version would be considered aristocratic: that it has been a small handful of entrepreneurs in each age that has advanced things. This in spite of the petty concerns of the proles, not because of them.
Re:Edward O. Wilson: Marx was right, he had the wrong species
by eru on Monday October 06, 2008 @06:09PM
(#325374)
No, elitism and free market do not have to go hand in hand.
For example look at the "I, Pencil" essay (http://www.econlib.org/library/Essays/rdPncl1.html) that argues that no single person knows how to make a pencil, at least not effectively. People of all walks of live contribute to our economy in varying degrees.
The history of science and technology is still told as the history of great men. Just look at the wealth of independent re-inventions, to see that seldom does progress hinge on individuals.
I still admire entrepeneurs and great scientists as great role models.
Re:Edward O. Wilson: Marx was right, he had the wrong species
by nazgulnarsil on Monday October 13, 2008 @06:22PM
(#331638)
wait what? what do you call the CEO of the pencil company? none of those individual workers would have jobs if the need for pencils didn't exist and there wasn't someone who was capitalizing on that need. That fact that the most efficient way of doing business in modern times involves shipping materials from many parts of the world is a testament to the efficiency of the market.
The command vs freee hand, particularly for physical goods production has been largely decided. I think very few politicians left that would directly control production in a red sort of a way. They might for micro political reasons, but probably wouldn't try to control the economy some other way.
Marx got moulded into a religious figure. But read in a similar context as Kant, Bentham, or even Ayn Rand, it's definitely interesting.