It's terrible in that a lot of the times smaller organic sites are much more relevant than big-box "trusted" sites.
That's why organic search algorithms are good.
Furthermore, there's a terrible burden for startups moving into certain spaces if suddenly you can't get ranked because you're not a Trusted source.
Plus, controlling search engine neutrality or listing position is not the business of the government or rightsholder. Remember, Google is a private entity.
Re:SOPA Hearing is Streaming Live
by feralchimp on Wednesday November 16, 2011 @01:33PM
(#3244374)
So instead of framing it in terms of "promoting known-legit" sites, what about "demote known-sketchy" sites?
Does that help your concerns about effects on unknowns, startups, etc? All the non-sketchy results should still be organically ranked, right?
Altering results (other than to show you the most relevant pages) ruins Google's perceived neutrality. All of a sudden Google becomes liable for showing you something they shouldn't, instead of being a neutral third-party.
If this is still a terrible idea, it's not an obviously terrible one.