News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Author Salman Rushdie attacked on lecture stage in New York by yardstick on Friday August 12, 2022 @11:44AM (#32440259)
What’s the solution here? How can people who embrace freedom of the press, freedom of opinion and people who violently disagree with such freedoms, live and thrive?
Re:Author Salman Rushdie attacked on lecture stage in New York by Comevius on Friday August 12, 2022 @12:17PM (#32440681)
Western democracies don't embrace absolute freedom, nor should they. Intolerating intolerance, violently if we must is the only way for tolerance to exist.

The only problem is that you need a value system geared toward long-term sustainability for any of this to be viable.

Re:Author Salman Rushdie attacked on lecture stage in New York by illuminerdy on Friday August 12, 2022 @01:04PM (#32441280)
> "Intolerating intolerance, violently if we must is the only way for tolerance to exist."

No, That literally is the antithesis of tolerance.

Also, IF (and that's a big if) some things are to be proscribed, they must be proscribed BY THE LAW and with DUE PROCESS, not "violently" as you claim.

Re:Author Salman Rushdie attacked on lecture stage in New York by npteljes on Friday August 12, 2022 @04:10PM (#32443324)
It maybe is on a theoretical level, but theoretical purity doesn't exist in the world - I think. At least we tried a bunch of times and it never worked so far. So, you end up with complex situations like this: not tolerating the intolerant, to sustain tolerance on the long term. Being very selectively violent, in order to keep peace. Restrict some freedoms, to enable wider freedoms. And so on.
Re:Author Salman Rushdie attacked on lecture stage in New York by illuminerdy on Friday August 12, 2022 @09:54PM (#32446187)
I don't understand what you mean by "being selectively violent".

Who decides when it's time to be "selectively violent" and who gets to apply this "selective violence"?

Because I'm sure this same principle of "selective violence" could be easily used (and would gladly be used) as justification by the folks who think they're "fighting fascism" and the like.

Re:Author Salman Rushdie attacked on lecture stage in New York by npteljes on Saturday August 13, 2022 @03:53AM (#32447795)
I was trying to refer to the concept of "monopoly on violence"[0], which is basically giving up the right to be violent, and enable violence to special groups and special occasions (think police, military) in order to have a peaceful society. You're very right that this is a hotbed of abuse, as I think every other power structure is.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monopoly_on_violence

Re:Author Salman Rushdie attacked on lecture stage in New York by Comevius on Friday August 12, 2022 @01:38PM (#32441697)
Who said anything about not having a due process. Of course we need a constitution, and need laws, but they are all worthless if you don't have a police and a military people can rely on. This is so obvious.
Re:Author Salman Rushdie attacked on lecture stage in New York by illuminerdy on Friday August 12, 2022 @10:03PM (#32446260)
Perhaps I misunderstood what you were saying. It sounded like you were saying that the general public should be violent towards people who are "intolerant" as a way to promote tolerance.

But now I see that that could not possibly have been what you meant because this isn't Twitter and people on this forum aren't that dumb.

Re:Author Salman Rushdie attacked on lecture stage in New York by davidivadavid on Friday August 12, 2022 @01:46PM (#32441800)
Re:Author Salman Rushdie attacked on lecture stage in New York by illuminerdy on Friday August 12, 2022 @10:15PM (#32446325)
"intolerant of the intolerant"

I don't like that phrase. Because it's extremely vague and implies that things other than physical violence could be a focus of suppression. Intolerant opinions and speech are not and should not be policed in any meaningful way. The free and open exchange of ideas is crucial to a free society. Even those that are "intolerant" or offensive.

And, after seeing what happened over the last couple of years, I wonder how far people these days would take "intolerance of the intolerant"? Can a person who is known to be "intolerant" be banned from a grocery store for no other reason than their opinions? Can they be banned from all grocery stores? Should they be? Should they be fired from their jobs? Should they be harassed whenever they leave their house?

There are way too many ways to abuse the notion that you should be "intolerant of the intolerant".

Re:Author Salman Rushdie attacked on lecture stage in New York by Comevius on Saturday August 13, 2022 @10:24AM (#32450193)
Free speech absolutism is not practical. Platforms like HN, Twitter, Facebook or Reddit would be quite hostile, it's like letting people out in the streets doing whatever they want. That's not practical.

The irony is that mainstream platforms tend to censor responsibly (even if false positives tend to occur due to the use of bots), while free speech absolutist platforms like Parler would ban you for merely having a different opinion.

The other irony is that free speech absolutists are responsible for nearly all the terror attacks in the United States. The harmful ideas of these absolutists are rejected by society for a reason, but this was the case even before the internet. Freedom of speech is not freedom of consequences.

Re:Author Salman Rushdie attacked on lecture stage in New York by curtainsforus on Sunday August 21, 2022 @07:29PM (#32545557)
If the whole world engages in witch-burning, and burn a lot of innocents along with the old women who poison wells, and you build a town and loudly declare it will have no witch-hunts, then you'll get people who want to live in that town- including a lot of witches.

HN, etc. really shouldn't be "platforms" moderated by a central entity, anyway. If I like Dang's moderation, I should be able to pick and choose it. Maybe there's another potential moderator out there whose sensibilities line up more neatly with my own; I should be able to choose their moderation, too.

Decentralized/splintered moderation, that's what we need.

(I've never been on Parler. Do they actually ban people for disagreeing with them?)

(Is it possible that rejecting people from society makes them more likely to be violent?)

Re:Author Salman Rushdie attacked on lecture stage in New York by s1artibartfast on Friday August 12, 2022 @12:48PM (#32441067)
And you also need an agreed definition for what types of tolerance are expected.

A fatwa is just a declaration of intolerance of intolerance, but with a different working definition.

Re:Author Salman Rushdie attacked on lecture stage in New York by Comevius on Friday August 12, 2022 @01:24PM (#32441518)
No definition is perfect, but there are objectively better and worst definitions. The German constitution called Basic Law is among the best definitions. It seeks to preserve human dignity and provide a decent set of rights, freedoms and equality. It seeks to uphold the division of powers.
Re:Author Salman Rushdie attacked on lecture stage in New York by s1artibartfast on Friday August 12, 2022 @02:31PM (#32442275)
I feel like constitutions are completely different than tolerance.

Tolerance in my mind is usually a cultural idea about how you teat legal behavior you disagree with.

How do you treat someone with different values that you disagree with.

Re:Author Salman Rushdie attacked on lecture stage in New York by jiscariot on Friday August 12, 2022 @01:33PM (#32441636)
The context of this story is words written on paper, not absolute freedom. Violence in response to words is an escalation, full stop. We don't need to go in to all that abysmal "paradox of tolerance" drivel to agree on this.
Re:Author Salman Rushdie attacked on lecture stage in New York by jedimind on Friday August 12, 2022 @02:02PM (#32441974)
How did no one ever think of this? We should have world peace by afternoon.
Re:Author Salman Rushdie attacked on lecture stage in New York by toyg on Friday August 12, 2022 @11:50AM (#32440343)
That's the paradox of open societies. Popper wrote a bunch about it.

Generally speaking, you just draw a line somewhere, and the open society ends there. Nazi apologist in Germany? You won't get the same privileges as the rest of the population. The challenge is to find a location for such line that is not clearly oppressive towards minorities with a right to exist (i.e. not the nazis).

Re:Author Salman Rushdie attacked on lecture stage in New York by kbelder on Friday August 12, 2022 @06:36PM (#32444784)
Tolerate speech. Don't tolerate violence.

It's not that hard in practical terms. Most children know this... it takes academic philosophers to turn it into a quaqmire.

Re:Author Salman Rushdie attacked on lecture stage in New York by SergeAx on Saturday August 13, 2022 @12:11PM (#32451182)
Homeini fatwah is literally a speech, but it calls to violence.
Re:Author Salman Rushdie attacked on lecture stage in New York by Ladioss on Saturday August 13, 2022 @02:25PM (#32452410)
Words do not bleed.
Re:Author Salman Rushdie attacked on lecture stage in New York by fellellor on Saturday August 13, 2022 @01:15AM (#32447135)
Gun.
Re:Author Salman Rushdie attacked on lecture stage in New York by djohnston on Friday August 12, 2022 @02:42PM (#32442408)
It's basically asking, how do we take a bunch of cavemen and stick them in Manhattan. Aside from hardcore segregation, it doesn't seem feasible.