> If it is the least-bad long term option
The thing is you have no way to know that in advance. And people may disagree what "least-bad" even means, it's extremely subjective.
I'm gonna disagree that deliberately killing innocent people is ever an ethically correct choice.
> I'm gonna disagree that deliberately killing innocent people is ever an ethically correct choice.
This is more or less the trolley problem, so as you say it is entirely subjective. We're just going to have to agree to disagree :)
If it is the least-bad long term option, that makes it in context the ethical choice. Hence, not an atrocity.