News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Robotic motion in curved space defies standard laws of ph... by fanick on Thursday August 11, 2022 @02:19AM (#32422179)
I suspect friction in the bearings is the culprit and allows for this "defiance of laws of physics".
Re:Robotic motion in curved space defies standard laws of ph... by hither_shores on Saturday August 13, 2022 @10:54PM (#32455931)
No, it really is possible to violate momentum conservation in suitably curved spacetimes. But this is a straightforward consequence of the laws of physics, not a "defiance" of them: it falls right out of general relativity. We still have a conservation law for the stress energy tensor, given by ∇_{μ}T^{μν}=0, it just doesn't give rise to separate global conservation laws on each component.

The same applies to the system they actually built, except that the nonconserved "momentum" is not the same as the usual notion. It's the conjugate momentum(https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canonical_coordinates) for the coordinates on the surface.

Re:Robotic motion in curved space defies standard laws of ph... by pmayrgundter on Saturday August 13, 2022 @11:38PM (#32456102)
Ok, interesting.

In the system you describe, is it possible for the center of gravity of an isolated system to move without ejecting mass or light?

Re:Robotic motion in curved space defies standard laws of ph... by hilbert42 on Sunday August 14, 2022 @12:01AM (#32456204)
What you say seems to make sense to me. Even if we understand the math of GR we've often still difficulties in interpreting the practicalities of it.

Besides, whenever we see statements about defying the laws of physics our immediate reaction should be to look deeper. Say, if some action seems to defy Newton then look to SR thence GR for the reason.

Re:Robotic motion in curved space defies standard laws of ph... by thethirdone on Saturday August 13, 2022 @09:56PM (#32455623)
It does seem that friction in the bearing and tension of the wires is not sufficiently controlled for the physical demonstration to be convincing.

However, the mathematics of it seems to have already been confirmed by a previous paper and the actual idea of changing orientation without exchanging momentum with anything is not novel.

You can turn a satellite by spinning up a flywheel and then reabsorbing the angular momentum when you reach the desired orientation.

Re:Robotic motion in curved space defies standard laws of ph... by 6510 on Sunday August 14, 2022 @02:18AM (#32456871)
> You can turn a satellite by spinning up a flywheel and then reabsorbing the angular momentum when you reach the desired orientation.

Wouldn't 2 of those allow for 2 different centers of rotation. If so, we can just walk though space.

:-)

Re:Robotic motion in curved space defies standard laws of ph... by colanderman on Sunday August 14, 2022 @02:26AM (#32456917)
No, the center of rotation is always that of the full system. It's not relative to which flywheel happens to be spinning.