Re:Google is mapping your wi-fi access point and the opt-out...
by lotu on Wednesday November 16, 2011 @02:33AM
(#3242225)
The collection of data was a result of Google storing the whole packet which was broadcast unencrypted for anyone to see. To me this is similar to not installing curtains in your house and then getting upset about people taking naked pictures of you. If privacy is important to then you have to take the first steps to protect it. It is unreasonable to put the burden of protecting your privacy entirely on everyone but you. If you don't bother to do something simple like encrypt your wifi I have to assume that means you don't care if it public. (I personally leave my wifi unencrypted for this exact reason.) As for cost and required knowledge installing curtains is probably trickier and more expensive then having the Geek Squad setup encrypted wifi.
Re:Google is mapping your wi-fi access point and the opt-out...
by DanBC on Wednesday November 16, 2011 @04:31AM
(#3242476)
People are stupid, but exploiting that stupidity is still evil. (I'm lousy at analogy, but here's an attempt: People dis-enrobing with no curtains are stupid, but it's the pervs who post pictures to the Internet; polite people glance and walk on.)
Even Google disagrees with you.
(http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/2010/may/15/google-admi...)
> "As soon as we became aware of this problem, we grounded our Street View cars and segregated the data on our network, which we then disconnected to make it inaccessible. We want to delete this data as soon as possible, and are currently reaching out to regulators in the relevant countries about how to quickly dispose of it."
Accessing a person's unencrypted wifi without their permission is, in England, a criminal offence and that's been tested by the courts.
(http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/technology/4721723.stm)
Having said all that, this German case says that people shouldn't be stupid and they are responsible for the security of their networks:
i) Google has unfortunate previous form. They've collected information from unsecured wifi, including snippets of emails; lists of people suffering from certain medical conditions; passwords; etc.
(http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-11797907)
They've made a "mistake" once. People want to be sure they don't make the same mistake again. (Scare quotes around mistake because, really, that's a lot of data to be accidentally scraping.)
ii) EU tends to prefer "Opt In" over "Opt Out", and it needs to be an explicit opt in. That means the company has to tell you what they're gathering, and why, and give you the choice to agree. Sure, that makes it very hard for companies to gather information (such as this which is on the very lower end of the privacy scale) and do useful cool things with that data. Some people (and I'm one of them) welcome the clear bright line that explicit opt in would draw between ethical companies (like Google; they're not evil and this wifi data gathering doesn't come close to being evil) and unpleasant seedy dodgy companies, who wouldn't bother obeying EU best practice data laws.