IANAP (physicist) but using this index it's hard not to imagine another place in the multiverse where this dark energy/matter cosmological model receives a high score on this rubric.
I agree it's probably very difficult to tell really novel and paradigm-shifting theories from the ramblings of cranks.
I suppose the Dark Matter model scores highly in some items of the Crackpot Index but very low in "the government is trying to suppress this", "everything they told you is a lie", and also the scientists who proposed it understood the established science and didn't randomly disregard it. I think the "conspiracy" aspect is what sets a crackpot apart.
Again, it's possible that a person is a crackpot AND he/she is also right about a particular theory!
"They are suppressing my work!"
"They do not want you to read this!"
Etc.
[1] https://math.ucr.edu/home/baez/crackpot.html