Re:A shuffled deck of cards is unique in all human history
by jfoutz on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @08:51PM
(#3241325)
The chances of you sharing a birthday with one of 22 other people is pretty low. the chances of at least two people in a group of 23 is 50%. In the first case, you're fixing the day that some other person must have.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:A shuffled deck of cards is unique in all human history
by sliverstorm on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @08:58PM
(#3241351)
In other words, the odds that a deck you are holding is unique are high; the odds that all decks ever shuffled are unique is low.
Re:A shuffled deck of cards is unique in all human history
by jgershen on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @09:17PM
(#3241412)
Actually, the probability that all decks ever shuffled are unique is also very high. We can approximate the probability that any two of the n decks shuffled in human history were identical as p=1-n^2/52!
Using the same estimate as the OP for n (1.56x10^23) gives p=3.02x10^-22. Still fantastically low.
Re:A shuffled deck of cards is unique in all human history
by gregable on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @09:44PM
(#3241485)
Nice, I came to the comments to see if someone knew how to calculate this.
Related question. If there are exactly 2N people who vote in a binary election (ie: for presidential candidates) and they have an even 50/50% chance of voting either way, how do I compute the odds that they will have a even split? This is a generous estimate for the probability my vote will matter.
Re:A shuffled deck of cards is unique in all human history
by wnoise on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @10:15PM
(#3241567)
The exact answer is (2n choose n) * (1/2)^(2n). This is approximately sqrt(1/Pi n) as n grows large, with error O(n^(-3/2))
Re:A shuffled deck of cards is unique in all human history
by flourpower on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @10:14PM
(#3241566)
That's the same as the probability that 2N flips of a fair coin result in exactly heads: (2N choose N)(.5^N)(.5^N).
Check out: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Binomial_distribution
Re:A shuffled deck of cards is unique in all human history
by JadeNB on Wednesday November 16, 2011 @10:38AM
(#3243464)
> We can approximate the probability that any two of the n decks shuffled in human history were identical as p=1-n^2/52!
I think that this is way too low. Shouldn't it be the quite large number
1 - \prod_{i = 1}^n (1 - (i - 1)/52!)
(a la the birthday paradox)?
Re:A shuffled deck of cards is unique in all human history
by JadeNB on Thursday November 17, 2011 @02:43PM
(#3248939)
Sorry, I was thinking of the complementary probability (that there has been a coincidence).
Mathematica overflowed when I tried to compute this by brute force. The next best thing I can think of is to use the exponential approximation
1 - x ≈ e^{-x},
good for very small `x`, such as ours. Ignoring the cascading errors gives \prod_{i = 1}^n (1 - (i - 1)/52!)
≈ \prod_{i = 1}^n e^{-(i - 1)/52!}
= e^{-n(n - 1)/52!}
≈ 1 - n(n - 1)/52!.
The error should be roughly of the size \frac1 2\sum_{i = 1}^n [(i - 1)/52!]^2
≈ n^3/(2(52!)^2),
which is relatively small. (That's stronger, here, than just saying that it is small.) That is to say: I guess I agree with jgershen after all!
Re:A shuffled deck of cards is unique in all human history
by sliverstorm on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @09:34PM
(#3241462)
Alright, fine, it is comparatively lower. Better? :)