Re:Show HN: The Captcha Experiment
by sray on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @08:36PM
(#3241278)
Without input validation, and without any clear motivation as top why this experiment was important, I was perfectly happy entering garbage or blank forms.
What I'm getting at is that without any real motivation for submitting a form, I don't really care what I enter. This is different than when I enter a captcha "in the wild" - in that case I would try really hard because I care about successfully submitting the form.
I'm not sure what this experiment is trying to prove, but without that motivation, I don't believe it's a proper simulation of real captcha use.
Re:Show HN: The Captcha Experiment
by astar on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @10:20PM
(#3241587)
coughgamificationcough
Just kidding. You could always do a drawing. Ask for a donated ipad. everyone who answers 100 or more catchpas correctly are eligible to be in the raffle.
What I'm getting at is that without any real motivation for submitting a form, I don't really care what I enter. This is different than when I enter a captcha "in the wild" - in that case I would try really hard because I care about successfully submitting the form.
I'm not sure what this experiment is trying to prove, but without that motivation, I don't believe it's a proper simulation of real captcha use.