News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Science Majors Change Their Minds by scott_s on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @06:26PM (#3240855)
I dunno, this distribution seems reasonable to me: 17% A's, 50% B's, 20% C's, 10% D's, and 3% F's

Are you saying that the caliber of student in the EECS department of Berkeley is so high that even the bottom 13% of the class would have gotten C's or B's at another school?

Re:Why Science Majors Change Their Minds by rayiner on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @10:57PM (#3241674)
The problem is the 3.0 median. At my law school, where most people majored in social sciences at places like Berkeley, Michigan, etc, 3.0 is a bottom of the barrel GPA in terms of getting admitted. I think the median is like 3.8. Our peer law schools won't even take someone with below a 3.2-3.3 or so. Meanwhile, 3.3 was a great GPA at the engineering department at Georgia Tech when I was there.

You can complain about grade inflation, etc, but at the end of the day you're telling that 18 year old kid: "don't even try to major in engineering, because even if you keep up with your highly qualified peers you'll still kill any shot you might have had at a non-engineering graduate program."

Re:Why Science Majors Change Their Minds by scott_s on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @11:04PM (#3241697)
I was comparing that distribution to the schools I've been a student and taught at (Virginia Tech, William and Mary) in CS. It seemed on par. Then the point is not about Berkeley, but all engineering departments.
Re:Why Science Majors Change Their Minds by grammr on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @07:47PM (#3241133)
> Are you saying that the caliber of student in the EECS department of Berkeley is so high that even the bottom 13% of the class would have gotten C's or B's at another school?

Certainly not any other school in general, but at your average university, probably yes. That's not so hard to believe given the competitiveness of Cal's engineering programs.

Re:Why Science Majors Change Their Minds by scott_s on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @08:24PM (#3241248)
I find it hard to believe. I've encountered - both as a student and as a teacher - too many bright, seemingly qualified students who just don't work hard enough and get their work done to accept that claim.
Re:Why Science Majors Change Their Minds by grammr on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @08:49PM (#3241315)
You very well could be right. But what's meaningful here is that Berkeley is hard, and that was the original point :)
Re:Why Science Majors Change Their Minds by unabridged on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @07:31PM (#3241086)
the people that just missed the cutoff for those spots are probably top of their class at whatever regional university they ended up going to.

also i'm sure there is some of that percentage that are capable but fucking off and not doing homework because they are 18 and just moved out of their parents house.

Re:Why Science Majors Change Their Minds by scott_s on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @07:42PM (#3241118)
the people that just missed the cutoff for those spots are probably top of their class at whatever regional university they ended up going to.

Entirely possible, but I think that says more about the capricious nature of admissions at elite colleges.