News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Noether's Theorem in a Nutshell (2020) by nh23423fefe on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @03:33PM (#32402984)
L <> d/dt S, because dS/dt = 0

S is a functional of q which is a function of t, the t binding doesn't really exist on the left to take a derivative.

every system minimizes the action. a subsystem is just some part of q (the coordinate of configuration space)

Actual trajectories don't conserve momentum though. A pendulum in a potential has varying momentum.

Re:Noether's Theorem in a Nutshell (2020) by sixo on Wednesday August 10, 2022 @11:38AM (#32413809)
I find this rather suspect. Write it as:

S[q(t), t_0, t] = int_{t_0}^{t} L(q(t'), q̇(t'), t') dt'

Formally, S is a function of the upper limit of integration, and dS/dt = L, yes? I don't see why we can't treat it this way. It is the arc-length formula of the space time metric, expressed as an integral in one privileged time coordinate ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relativistic_Lagrangian_mechan... ). Though, it's Lorentz invariant, and we could express it as an integral along the trajectory of the particle, in which case it's just = a constant factor * the proper time. The whole idea of "varying q while keeping the boundaries q[t_0], q[t], t_0, and t fixed" is perfectly understandable as a condition on q, but doesn't stop us from using the formula for S in other ways--for one, to come up with a general principle behind the condition on q.

Actual trajectories of closed systems do conserve momentum. The earth is interacting with the pendulum.

Re:Noether's Theorem in a Nutshell (2020) by nh23423fefe on Thursday August 11, 2022 @10:46AM (#32426524)
Hmm I still don't see why you can make that argument?

I'm thinking that by chain rule d/dt S = dq/dt dS/dq. But we assert that the variation of S is zero for real trajectories. so dS/dq = 0

Re:Noether's Theorem in a Nutshell (2020) by sixo on Thursday August 18, 2022 @10:57AM (#32510566)
There's no way that's right. It's mixing up "t" as the upper limit of integration (S[q] is really S[q, t_0, t]) vs t as the argument of q; dS/dt in the latter sense doesn't even make sense because the argument of q is "integrated out" in the expression of S.
Re:Noether's Theorem in a Nutshell (2020) by hither_shores on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @05:33PM (#32404630)
> every system minimizes the action

Action is stationary, not necessarily minimal.