News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GitHub deleted accounts of people who contributed to Torn... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @10:57AM (#32398910)
> What separates pre-sanctions Tornado from any other tech that can feasibly be used for something evil (e.g. cash money, PayPal, any cryptocurrency, e2ee messengers)?

I don’t have the technical answer. But from the instant tumblers became a thing everyone with AML experience saw the endgame. It’s providing, as a service, a function directly analogous to real-world layering. It does nothing else. And nobody involved seems to have taken the prospect of criminals using their product seriously.

Messengers are not money, so laundering goes out the window. PayPal is regulated. And crypto does other things. Tornado just served to hide the origin of money. And it was used to launder illegally-gotten gains.

Re:GitHub deleted accounts of people who contributed to Torn... by mindslight on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @12:46PM (#32400353)
The fundamental problem is that "money laundering" is an oxymoron, because money is fungible. So the government has created an always-applicable law, pinky-swore to only use it to prosecute "bad guys" (like many federal add-on laws), and is now expanding their scope to persecute a project that mitigates a general security vulnerability that exists in most cryptocurrencies, because the existence of that vulnerability hinders criminals.
Re:GitHub deleted accounts of people who contributed to Torn... by pcwalton on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @01:45PM (#32401218)
The definition of money laundering is concealing the origin of money obtained from an illegal source. You may not like the fact that this is illegal, but it has a clear definition and most people want it to be outlawed, so it is. It's obviously not "always applicable": I've never taken steps to conceal ill-gotten gains and neither have the vast majority of people.
Re:GitHub deleted accounts of people who contributed to Torn... by mindslight on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @02:20PM (#32401751)
Sure, the requirement for an "illegal source" is what made for an "add on" charge - something else illegal had to have been going on for it to apply. But here it is being used by itself to go after a piece of software that provides general financial privacy to anybody, and not merely financial privacy for criminals. So that detail of its definition isn't particularly relevant any more, and it makes sense to talk about the contradictory framing of the concept.

A traditional banking analog would be if the feds went after brick and mortar banks for allowing customers to deposit checks from named payors and withdraw cash or create a new check. A law-abiding customer might take advantage of this property to receive a paycheck from an abortion clinic and then make a donation to their church. Whereas a criminal might use the same scrubbing to receive a payment from a known drug dealer and then turn around and pay their mortgage. Yet the bank's whole business isn't declared a priori illegal due to concealing the origin of the funds on the outgoing payment.

Re:GitHub deleted accounts of people who contributed to Torn... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @02:33PM (#32401970)
> it is being used by itself to go after a piece of software that provides general financial privacy to anybody, and not merely financial privacy for criminals

The archetypal laundromat also does normal folks’ laundry. It just also launders money for criminals. I’m sure they would happily layer money for non-criminals but nobody does that.

> banking analog would be if the feds went after brick and mortar banks for allowing customers to deposit checks and withdraw cash

If they did that without checking anyone’s identity and then, after learning—from law enforcement no less—that criminals were using them to launder money, kept going, business as usual, hell yes they’d be shut down and arrested.

Re:GitHub deleted accounts of people who contributed to Torn... by mindslight on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @02:46PM (#32402171)
> I’m sure they would happily layer money for non-criminals but nobody does that.

This thread is full of these blind assertions that nobody except criminals wants financial privacy. They are patently false.

> If they did that without checking anyone’s identity and then, after learning—from law enforcement no less—that criminals were using them to launder money, kept going, business as usual, hell yes they’d be shut down and arrested.

You're basically saying that once a service gets used by a criminal, then operating that service becomes illegal because it is furthering criminal acts. This seems like yet another Godelesque everything-is-criminalized result, and your appeal that one can avoid persecution by electing to perform blanket investigation on all one's customers isn't particularly redeeming.

Like sure I get the traditional banking industry has been practically inundated with these type of invasive heavyhanded regulations to make things easier for law enforcement, but that's not a particularly compelling argument.

Re:GitHub deleted accounts of people who contributed to Torn... by jakelazaroff on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @03:21PM (#32402765)
> You're basically saying that once a service gets used by a criminal, then operating that service becomes illegal because it is furthering criminal acts.

If the operators know that people are using their service to launder money, and they keep operating their service without doing anything to prevent that, then… yes? What do you think should happen? They just get to keep doing crime?

Re:GitHub deleted accounts of people who contributed to Torn... by mindslight on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @03:28PM (#32402910)
Try applying your argument to the electric company. If a service operator has knowledge of a specific crime being committed one can make the argument that they're obligated to report the known details. But in general knowing that nonspecific criminals may be using your service does not imply that you have to shut your service down to hinder those criminals.
Re:GitHub deleted accounts of people who contributed to Torn... by jakelazaroff on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @03:56PM (#32403386)
Tornado Cash isn't an electric company, though. There are different rules. Financial institutions are often subject to KYC rules that require them to proactively vet their customers.

You're writing as though this were uncharted legal territory, trying to reason from first principles when you can truly consider a business a criminal enterprise, but we've had laws on the books for decades for the express purpose of stopping people from doing exactly what Tornado Cash does.

Re:GitHub deleted accounts of people who contributed to Torn... by mindslight on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @04:43PM (#32404023)
The traditional financial system has coasted along on having two different sets of rules - one for consumer-facing things where you can do whatever you want with anonymous cash up to a certain amount, and one for Big Serious Transactions. The distinction between those two regimes is breaking down, and I don't want to see consumer privacy get left behind. Thus it's appropriate to reason from first principles about what ought to be, and not simply what regulations law enforcement has been able to get pushed through to make their own jobs easier. Individuals should not have everything we purchase be permanently recorded in order to convince us to buy more crap or price discriminate or whatever. Financial privacy is a key part of that.
Re:GitHub deleted accounts of people who contributed to Torn... by throwaway290 on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @11:31AM (#32399340)
I do not see a meaningful difference between e2ee messengers and mixers. Both aim to support anonymity. Both can (and do) enable bad things. If you (unlike me) believe that cryptocurrency should be legal, I don't see why you would think mixers should not.

Now it is moot after sanctions are in effect. What we are discussing is mental world model of software engineers before Tornado sanctions were announced and their accounts wiped. It might be hard to see in hindsight.