News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Possible Fix for Scientific Publishing by j-pb on Monday August 08, 2022 @04:55AM (#32383533)
Theres an issue with this "one review fits all" approach. Scientific communities are often splintered into sub-communities with different views and allegiances.

The scientific community is not a set, it's a graph with different connectedness and weights.

A imho better system would:

* use public key crypto to give everybody a pseudonym under which they can create, sign and publish articles

* a publication graph that is used both as a reference system and a review system;

    - a reference is a link from one article to another if it reuses and builds upon it (standing on the shoulder of giants)

    - a review is a link from one article to another that passes judgement on or reproduces that article (peer review)
* a sentiment analysis based system that turns the review links into peer-review quality metrics

* a way to delegate judgement from yourself to others that you trust in your community

* a page-rank like algorithm that computes trust relative to your private key and the trust it has assigned/delegated

* and most importantly: a UI that shows you a papers ranking and relevance based on YOUR personal trust graph and community

There are no comments on this comment yet.