News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GraphQL kinda sucks by NonNefarious on Saturday August 06, 2022 @11:01AM (#32368706)
Yep. I worked at a place that fired almost its entire programming staff because they insisted on using Visual C++ to build a CRUD app, while a team of contractors built a prototype in Visual Basic.

Needless to say, the VB app worked fine and became the product.

Re:GraphQL kinda sucks by diarrhea on Saturday August 06, 2022 @12:17PM (#32369361)
If you don't mind, would you explain this more? I don't understand the implications; VB does sound "worse" than Visual C++ for such a job, from an outsider perspective?
Re:GraphQL kinda sucks by CRConrad on Monday August 08, 2022 @12:01PM (#32387213)
> VB does sound "worse" than Visual C++ for such a job

Huh? No no, on the contrary: Straightforward CRUD apps, that's exactly what VB was built for and excels at. Only Delphi is better.

The thing about "Visual" C++ is that it isn't (or at least wasn't, last I looked) really very visual at all. And that sucks for building simple in-house CRUD apps, where the VB / Delphi drag-and-drop UI builder paradigm is a huge productivity multiplier.

Re:GraphQL kinda sucks by koonsolo on Saturday August 06, 2022 @02:05PM (#32370259)
In C++ you have to manage your own memory. Why would you want to do that when you're simply pushing data around.

I wouldn't choose VB myself, but when it's between VB and C++ for simple data pushing, I would indeed choose VB.

Let's say it like this: if you need to move stuff, would you choose a F1 car or a minivan. I would pick the minivan.

Re:GraphQL kinda sucks by NonNefarious on Saturday August 06, 2022 @02:16PM (#32370344)
No problem. At the time, Visual C++ lacked several important OCX controls that were included with VB, so they had to be hand-coded.

If you were building an application that does little more than populate forms with data from a database and then update the database, VB was totally adequate. The most important part of the job was the DB and query design.

Re:GraphQL kinda sucks by mechanical_bear on Saturday August 06, 2022 @01:28PM (#32369934)
Why is this “needless to say”, as if it should be apparent to anyone?
Re:GraphQL kinda sucks by NonNefarious on Saturday August 06, 2022 @02:20PM (#32370367)
Because a CRUD app doesn't require any serious computing performance from the application, making C++ unnecessary. If another implementation won the race to functional completion, then... needless to say... it was the one to go with.

Today you'd probably just use browser-based UI.

Also if you've spent time in corporate development (rather than a software company), I think this scenario is a common one. If you show management a prototype that works, they're going to ask why we don't just make that the product. And if you don't have a good reason... you don't have a good reason.