Re:Anti-Hacking Law Criminalizes Most Computer Users, Former...
by mindslight on Monday November 14, 2011 @07:18PM
(#3236312)
It'd be nicer if he had realized the fallacies of the prevailing 'legal' environment before he signed up to be a prosecutor (specifically, widespread laws make everyone guilty of something, so enforcement is really more about your place in society). Instead he was a cog in the system long enough to unjustly ruin some people's lives, then suddenly gets some critical thinking skills. Is it really that hard to think through your actions beforehand?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Anti-Hacking Law Criminalizes Most Computer Users, Former...
by JadeNB on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @01:17AM
(#3237258)
Are all prosecutions unjust? Do you know his record? How do you know he ruined people's lives?
If someone is ignorant of the flaws in the system before he joins it, but dedicates himself to righting them once he discovers them, should that then expose him to this sort of scorn?
Re:Anti-Hacking Law Criminalizes Most Computer Users, Former...
by mindslight on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @01:03PM
(#3239272)
Prosecutions are conducted under the guise of due process, but are anything but. Certainly many who are prosecuted are guilty, but chances are there was at least one innocent person under the steamroller that this guy was helping drive.
For one, he gets the scorn because all the people who groomed him into thinking he was "building a better world" aren't in the spotlight. If he's truly repetant, he can reflect upon how they misled him and adjust his personal opinion accordingly.
But really, he's pointing out one law lacking due process like it's the exception. It's not. The whole system has cargo-culted the idea of justice, going through the motions so outsiders think there's intelligence and justice behind it.