News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What is the cost of a cashless society? by jeroenhd on Friday August 05, 2022 @04:25AM (#32353237)
I think a cashless society can work perfectly well. There's a single place that I still use cash with because they don't take card (probably avoiding tax) so every time I go there, I come back with change to tip to delivery people when I order food. Everything from my rent to my grocery shopping is done digitally and I honestly think it's great.

However, that's probably because I live in a debit-based country. Debit cards without overdraft capabilities should be readily available even to people with no financial skills because you can't use them to spend more than you earn, making the risk to the banks themselves minimal. The small fee paid for banking services is the only thing at risk and even that won't have much of an impact on the bank in general.

Some countries, most importantly probably the USA, almost exclusively operate on credit cards for digital money, which are practically quick instant loans that you don't want to think about. There's very little in there to limit your credit card spending to your actual income and some people are foolish or desperate enough to borrow money to pay off loans, with credit cards being one of the easiest options. People with poor or no financial skills will run up a debt and quickly stop qualifying for credit, and the end result is that they're dependent on cash or even something as archaic as cheques to transfer money in stores. The extreme impact credit scores can have in the States is mind boggling but it almost looks like people accept some shady third party evaluating their entire life for fraud risk as a normal thing.

If your standard modus operandi is spending money that you'll have to pay back later, I don't think your society can be cashless. Normalise debit cards as standard payment systems and almost everyone can qualify. Frauds will find themselves struggling to get an affordable bank account, but in a modern banking system there are plenty of alternatives available.

Based on this article, Canada clearly needs a banking overhaul for any cashless ambitions to stick without dire consequences.

Re:What is the cost of a cashless society? by mdp2021 on Friday August 05, 2022 @05:42AM (#32353769)
> society ... that's probably

You are creating a log of "everything you do", available to third parties, both statal and private. «That's probably» more because of lack of sense of "creepy".

And «that's probably» also because you are not considering the infrastructure required, such as that time in spring the shop owner in front of me was having a nervous breakdown as a blackout had his transaction equipment off. In normal times you give a banknote, take change and the fiscal registration will be postponed to after the blackout. In cretinous times, there will be no purchase. I was there to buy water.

Re:What is the cost of a cashless society? by jeroenhd on Friday August 05, 2022 @08:56AM (#32355408)
Good infrastructure is definitely one of the many requirements for a cashless society. I've personally experienced a blackout that lasted longer than 30 minutes and even then the amount of blackouts I've encountered can be counted on one hand. During those the cell tower backups managed to maintain connectivity for at least 15 minutes. Any store that invested in an UPS for their checkout systems would've just kept going for the entire time the power was out, maybe at a little slower rate because of the sudden influx of connections to the cell towers.

"What if the power goes out" is a question that needs to be answered for any part of society relying on technology, which, with the rise of ICS and IoT systems, is already affecting everything around us. Bridges will be stuck open (or closed), train will stop and grind to a halt, the shipping industry will grind to a halt, hospitals won't work for more than a day, electric cars will be unusable even sooner, the list goes on.

Good digital and electrical infrastructure is far from available everywhere, and in areas where it's not, a completely cashless society is simply not a good idea.

Re:What is the cost of a cashless society? by mellavora on Friday August 05, 2022 @07:39AM (#32354693)
Wait- your argument that a cashless society can work well is that debit cards can be distributed to everyone, and debit cards limit bank risk?

which boils down to: "a cashless society can work well because we can use tech to make society cashless."

this is not a substantive argument.

Re:What is the cost of a cashless society? by jeroenhd on Friday August 05, 2022 @08:44AM (#32355267)
There is more to a cashless society than debit cards and tech. It can work because for a great many people it works already.

However, I don't see any cashless society working well with credit based systems, simply because of the credit score/debt history connection.

Re:What is the cost of a cashless society? by perf1 on Friday August 05, 2022 @04:43AM (#32353363)
It's a receipt for disaster. Especially if they centralize it even more by replacing banks with a Central Bank that fully controls the Digital Currency. Which they are already planning and testing. This will be misused. And people can be controlled with this in a really bad way. If your Social Credit Score is low you could be taxed higher or even forbidden to drive your car or travel, for example. Your food choices could be restricted at any moment too if you don't behave.
Re:What is the cost of a cashless society? by jeroenhd on Friday August 05, 2022 @08:46AM (#32355292)
You don't need a cashless society for any of that. Background checks and basic identification requirements can already impose oppressive regulation on everyone even if the products are paid for by cash.

Cash is just an IOU for the bank that can be devalued at any point in time. If you want to avoid government oppression, go back to bartering rare metals. "Yes but what if the government turns oppressive" isn't an avoidable scenario, cashless or not.