News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hyundai rolls out 27 heavy-duty hydrogen trucks in Germany by ClumsyPilot on Thursday August 04, 2022 @12:07PM (#32344724)
The solution for electric trucking has been obvious for 50 years - overhead cables on all major highways.

It is the cheapest and most efficient solution, the trucks only need enough range for local delivery and transport, and since they charge from cables, they dont occupy petrol stations.

https://movemnt.net/uk-trial-to-electrify-30km-of-motorway-w...

Re:Hyundai rolls out 27 heavy-duty hydrogen trucks in Germany by somethoughts on Thursday August 04, 2022 @01:12PM (#32345569)
Tom Scott did a video on it:

The highway where trucks work like electric trains

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_3P_S7pL7Yg

Its interesting if it could be used in combination with self driving truck technology for long haul train style trucking.

Re:Hyundai rolls out 27 heavy-duty hydrogen trucks in Germany by nimbleplum40 on Thursday August 04, 2022 @12:09PM (#32344743)
> The solution for electric trucking has been obvious for 50 years - overhead cables on all major highways.

Not necessarily disagreeing, but if the solution has been obvious for 50 years, why hasn't it happened?

Re:Hyundai rolls out 27 heavy-duty hydrogen trucks in Germany by 0xbadcafebee on Thursday August 04, 2022 @02:11PM (#32346324)
Because the logistics never worked, and won't work for at least another 10 years.

1. How do you use it? First you need an electric truck, or a truck where at least 50% of its wheels are connected to electric motors. Either way you'd have to retrofit existing fleets of all shapes and sizes, so one or more companies would need to specialize in doing that, which would be very expensive initially. So you have to have an electric fleet to retrofit, or retrofit an ICE fleet (which makes zero economic sense).

2. How often is it used? The truck might actually only spend 1/2-2/3 of its time connected to the system, what with time waiting to load/unload at ports and depots, time before/after you're on highway, dealing with traffic on the highway itself.

3. How do you pay for the energy? You need a company to generate the energy, a company to charge users for the energy, a way to identify the truck as it's receiving the energy, tariff management software, etc.

4. Where are you going to install it? What roads will or won't work? How long will that take before you have enough roads that you'd stop losing money? Mostly long haul, so this has limited application, even in trucking.

If all the trucks were electric, all exactly the same size/type, the system were installed on all roads, all the companies needed to service it were in operation, and you trained enough service staff, and electricity was cheap enough that the portion of your ride would be offset by the amount of time you are charging that you could carry a smaller battery, then it would make sense.

But first we need to roll this system out on all highways, then everybody needs a BEV, then we retrofit them all, then shrink all their batteries, and then it will make economic sense. Before that all happens we need enough chargers, enough grid capacity, cheaper cleaner power, and enough BEVs rolled out, which will take 10 years at least.

Electric trams work in cities because they have short routes, a small identical fleet, need very little battery, and all the money comes from one pool (the city).

Re:Hyundai rolls out 27 heavy-duty hydrogen trucks in Germany by ClumsyPilot on Thursday August 04, 2022 @07:14PM (#32349499)
> first we need to roll this system out on all highways, then everybody needs a BEV

Essentially your complaint seems to be that we don't get a free lunch, but that's never been an option

You have only 3 options: large expensive batteries on every truck, smaller batteries + overhead wires, or some kind of fuel like hydrogen. In all cases you need new vehicles, and in all cases you need new infrastructure to handle charging and/or fuel.

Production of fuel from electricity and it's distribution is always under 40% efficiency. So if you want efficiency, the only question is cost of overhead wires vs cost of larger battery in every truck.

Most of the battery would be spent travelling long distance on large, straight roads, and those are also the easiest roads to electrify.

Also what's with the complaint about energy billing? We can put a 5g connection into every car and make it charge us for heated seats, but measuring energy is a problem?

Re:Hyundai rolls out 27 heavy-duty hydrogen trucks in Germany by elihu on Thursday August 04, 2022 @08:32PM (#32350094)
You just need electric trucks with one pair of drive wheels powered by electric motors. Maybe more if you want more traction, but an 18-wheeler doesn't need 9 drive wheels. It might have 8, if the tractor has two drive axles with dual tires. In practice you could just replace the engine with an electric motor and keep the rest of the drive train the same, as is done on many EV conversions now.

If the system is on the major roads, then that's where the major energy is being used. If you're stuck somewhere in traffic or waiting to load/unload, you're not actually using much energy.

Honestly I'd be okay with the energy being unmetered. I think the cost to society of CO2 emissions is probably greater than the cost of supplying trucks with free energy would be anyways, so I think it's probably a net win for society to have it as a free service. But there are also ways to charge for it if we wanted to go that route. Paying for the energy is a non-problem, you'd just need to decide on a policy.

Ideally in the U.S. this would be installed on interstate highways, at regular intervals. Maybe 5 miles on, 20 miles off or something like that. The overhead lines don't need to be everywhere, they just need to be in enough places that cross-country shipping is possible, and local shipping between major cities is possible.

Re:Hyundai rolls out 27 heavy-duty hydrogen trucks in Germany by myself248 on Thursday August 04, 2022 @01:55PM (#32346119)
Same reason Detroit doesn't have useful mass-transit.

Entrenched interests make more money by prolonging the problem. Arguably the solution would be economically superior (vastly so!), but the folks who'd profit from it aren't in power _now_, and government lacks both the technical competency to understand what to do, and the balls to do it.

Re:Hyundai rolls out 27 heavy-duty hydrogen trucks in Germany by elihu on Thursday August 04, 2022 @08:13PM (#32349969)
Because historically diesel has been cheap and the externalities have been ignored. It's also a major infrastructure project, and getting it installed widely enough to be useful on, say, the interstate highway system in the U.S. would require an act of Congress, plus buy-in from vehicle manufacturers and operators, plus widely-agreed on standards.
Re:Hyundai rolls out 27 heavy-duty hydrogen trucks in Germany by ClumsyPilot on Thursday August 04, 2022 @12:11PM (#32344785)
I mean, we still haven't even electrified all the railways, and the proposal for IceLink, a cable to import cheap renewable power from IceLand to UK, was sitting on the shelf for 60 years.

Also we had trolleybusses in many cities and got rid of them

Re:Hyundai rolls out 27 heavy-duty hydrogen trucks in Germany by throwaway894345 on Thursday August 04, 2022 @02:06PM (#32346275)
So why isn't it widely deployed in Europe where they do have electrified railways, etc?
Re:Hyundai rolls out 27 heavy-duty hydrogen trucks in Germany by xputer on Thursday August 04, 2022 @10:22PM (#32350764)
Probably because you still need battery power for the non freeway portion of the trip.
Re:Hyundai rolls out 27 heavy-duty hydrogen trucks in Germany by _ph_ on Thursday August 04, 2022 @12:11PM (#32344780)
Germany is currently testing this on some selected sections.
Re:Hyundai rolls out 27 heavy-duty hydrogen trucks in Germany by panick21_ on Thursday August 04, 2022 @01:26PM (#32345748)
If that is the case, and I agree. We should actually put much, much more effort into cargo railway first. And the same for trams as well.

But that shouldnt prevent us from trolly lines on highways.

Re:Hyundai rolls out 27 heavy-duty hydrogen trucks in Germany by elihu on Thursday August 04, 2022 @09:30PM (#32350404)
I very much agree we should be electrifying our major roads.

There's a couple ways to do this though with pros and cons. Overhead lines are cheapest, but they'd need to be high enough that they'd be impractical for passenger cars to access.

Rails embedded in the road are a technology that's being tested in Sweden[1]. It's a bit more expensive to install, but the advantages are that it can be used by both cars and trucks, and it's less visible than the overhead lines (which some people find unattractive).

A third option is wireless, which is the most expensive and the amount of power you can practically transmit is a lot less than the other two methods.

I think the rails option is probably best if we want to kill the range anxiety issue for trucking and personal vehicles at the same time, but there are good arguments for the overhead lines too.

[1] https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2018/apr/12/worlds-f...

Re:Hyundai rolls out 27 heavy-duty hydrogen trucks in Germany by throwaway894345 on Thursday August 04, 2022 @12:12PM (#32344802)
Your link doesn't support your claims (that it has been "obvious for 50 years" or that it's the cheapest and most efficient solution). I don't doubt that it's cheaper and more efficient than large BEVs, but like the other commenters, I would like to know where this has been conclusively studied and why this hasn't been deployed at scale anywhere.

> they dont occupy petrol stations

In the US they usually have their own stations.

EDIT: Downvoters, care to explain?

Re:Hyundai rolls out 27 heavy-duty hydrogen trucks in Germany by upupandup on Thursday August 04, 2022 @05:41PM (#32348662)
It's not really up to commentators to post links, if something irks you this much, google is there for you to verify.

HN is not a court of law and you are gonna have a tough time making friends if you ask for citation for every statement you hear.

Re:Hyundai rolls out 27 heavy-duty hydrogen trucks in Germany by throwaway894345 on Thursday August 04, 2022 @10:18PM (#32350739)
You misunderstood the context. I didn’t request a citation, I pointed out that the provided citation didn’t support the provided claims. I mentioned that I would be interested in learning more, but that’s not the same thing as insisting on a citation.