I'm not very familiar with how Jetbrains products handle Git — if it has everything you're looking for, I understand it can be a hard sell.

Most of our users enjoy Tower's ease of use, with features such as drag and drop to perform most tasks (including rebasing, cherry-picking, etc) or the possibility to undo pretty much everything (probably my favorite feature: https://www.git-tower.com/features/undo/mac). Many complex Git actions (e.g.: branch comparison or solving merging conflicts) are very simple to perform in Tower.

If you ever find the time, I suggest you give our trial version a shot!