It really comes down to what you mean by "better for the economy". When most people care about the economy, what they really care about is how much "stuff" they or the average person can buy.
To one extreme, many people would still be unhappy if the GDP and "economy" doubled, but only 10% of people were working. Either 90% of people would be going without, or they would be on some sort of welfare taxed from the 10%.
To the other extreme, many people would be unhappy if there were 100% employment, but all you could buy with it is a loaf of bread.
The ideal is to have high labor demand (usually associated with high employment) and growing GDP. This means that people who want to work can easily get a job, and the amount of "stuff" they can get from working keeps going up.
However, it is bad if 2 people have to work for the same income that one person made before.
Employment has gone up 1% but inflation adjusted wages have gone down ~10%.
And wages are becoming a larger part of the inflation picture, since gas and commodity food prices are currently falling but wages are still going up.
This is like saying sure you can't buy as much bread, but at least you are working longer.
The fact that more people are working to produce less than before describes an economy in decline.
Working more or longer isn't a good thing in its own right. In fact, it is bad it you are working more for less purchasing power.
Employment growth has historically been associated with increased purchasing power, but the current situation is a deviation from this norm.
Talking about employment growth ignoring this fact is a bit of a bait and switch playing on this incorrect association.