Re:MIT invents $4 solar desalination device
by ChadNauseam on Wednesday August 03, 2022 @06:50AM
(#32330013)
I think giving people (not local governments) money would typically help them develop faster than deciding for them what to spend the money on. But a country can’t develop without decent institutions and I agree that you have to work around the constraints created by governmental corruption.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:MIT invents $4 solar desalination device
by throwaway0a5e on Wednesday August 03, 2022 @07:37AM
(#32330336)
>I think giving people (not local governments) money
And what stops the local government from trying to take a big cut?
Re:MIT invents $4 solar desalination device
by DubiousPusher on Wednesday August 03, 2022 @09:54AM
(#32331676)
You realize corrupt indivisuala and governments get their fingers into the specific aid that flows through NGOs as well right?
Re:MIT invents $4 solar desalination device
by throwaway0a5e on Wednesday August 03, 2022 @03:23PM
(#32335761)
Of course. But you plant an liquid asset somewhere and the best they can do is tax it. You move fungible stuff like money or staple grains around and a lot more is going to evaporate along the way.
Re:MIT invents $4 solar desalination device
by tdeck on Thursday August 04, 2022 @03:17AM
(#32340128)
They can force you to hire their contractors for construction and delivery, at an exorbitant price to fund kickbacks. They can have you install infrastructure on public land and then seize that land and use it for an aristocrat's private residence. They can restrict the places you can build infrastructure to provinces that recently favored the ruling party to curry political favor. There are plenty of ways for despots to profit off of "development" projects beyond taxation.
Re:MIT invents $4 solar desalination device
by ChadNauseam on Wednesday August 03, 2022 @08:08AM
(#32330605)
good question, maybe you give the money continuously (every month or so) and commit to stop giving it if the local government tries to take too big a cut – then their incentive to start taking a cut would be limited
Re:MIT invents $4 solar desalination device
by replygirl on Wednesday August 03, 2022 @11:03AM
(#32332715)
look up your senators' investments!
Re:MIT invents $4 solar desalination device
by hulitu on Wednesday August 03, 2022 @09:19AM
(#32331313)
corruption.
Re:MIT invents $4 solar desalination device
by eurasiantiger on Wednesday August 03, 2022 @07:34AM
(#32330310)
I agree on the principle: giving money to people whose personal development is hindered by poverty obviously allows them to overcome the hindrance.
However, this does not mean that giving money to people is going to make those people want to develop themselves and their surroundings, unless they are already in the process of doing so.
Re:MIT invents $4 solar desalination device
by DubiousPusher on Wednesday August 03, 2022 @09:56AM
(#32331710)
The British ca. 1910 would certainly agree.