> recovered most of that from insurance claims anyway
Insurance companies don't lose money in the long run, so Exxon paid that money too.
Insurance companies make extra money by charging for more risk than is actually present. One way they can do that is by making certain things a condition of insurability.
If you think BP is going to pay anything close to the cost of the Deepwater Horizon spill, you really haven't been paying attention. The fact is that buying a stake in the legislature and the courts provides a much better ROI than investing in cleanup technologies.