Re:Carbon’s most exciting feature is its calling convention
by simiones on Tuesday August 02, 2022 @05:42AM
(#32316757)
> What allows you to say that they have different identities?
Syntactic analogy with non-zero sized types. If you want a special case that says "there is a single object of the zero-sized type" that's ok, but it's a special case. All other types have a difference between object identity and value equality.
> Will all addresses be equal?
No, because C++ doesn't optimize for ZSTs, and it doesn't modify semantics for const. I agree that C++ pays a price for these two things, but I don't think it's because it "insists all objects have different addresses", I believe that is just a consequence to not giving special semantics to const beyond disallowing writes.
What allows you to say that they have different identities? They are zero-sized types. Literally zero. `()` is a type and `()` its the only possible value. log(1) = 0 bit. If you look into machine code you will not find anything that you can call an object. The very existence of `()` is a shared dream of a programmer and compiler, and `()` ceased to exist after a compilation.
> But imagine the following program
In this program you are using types of size > 0bit, which allows more than 1 value of that type. But even then I wouldn't bet that they are different objects only because you changed one. If you didn't, it would be completely logical to replace them all with just one value in a memory, while pretending that there are many copies of it.
In this particular case I don't believe rustc would manage to do it even if we drop mutation from the example. And I can't think of a case when it will manage. But I wouldn't bet that such case doesn't exist.
> By the way, note that your example should be completely equivalent to the following C++ program
Hmm... And if we write in C++ something like:
Will we get an output like this: Will all addresses be equal? If they are, then the proposition "C++ also pays a price for insisting not only that objects have addresses, but those addresses are distinct"* is false.