I reckon nobody opposes your fine idea, simply that when a template is transformed enough to be a useful web app starting point, it's often too opinionated to be generally applicable! But maybe the next time I start a few web apps I will think about how I can keep it a clean template as long as possible -- might go somewhere cool.
The pervasive "compostable library" mindset also completely ignores the other benefits of having a standardized framework such as Rails that people can rally around: 1. Standardized documentation 2. Being able to create community that can provide support when you're having issues 3. Easily google-able solutions to common issues 4. A standard that can be iterated upon. I feel like Clojure libraries do this somewhat already so they can work with each other so what's the harm on standardizing these interfaces?