News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: When do you think Wayland will be broadly supported? by Amezarak on Saturday July 30, 2022 @12:56PM (#32288288)
Glad to hear it is possible, but I need it to be default and correctly configured on all Wayland installs to be useful.
Re:Ask HN: When do you think Wayland will be broadly supported? by Crysstalis on Saturday July 30, 2022 @02:07PM (#32288917)
No, you can just install it if you need it. It is just another package, there is no special reason it needs to be default.
Re:Ask HN: When do you think Wayland will be broadly supported? by Amezarak on Saturday July 30, 2022 @04:06PM (#32289828)
Many of us work in worlds where we absolutely cannot just install packages. Solutions that aren’t default are solutions we can’t use. And X forwarding is available by default - losing that is regression.
Re:Ask HN: When do you think Wayland will be broadly supported? by Crysstalis on Saturday July 30, 2022 @05:03PM (#32290307)
If you cannot install any packages at all without major hassle, then I think you would have a lot worse problems in many other areas besides this. As I said elsewhere in the thread, X11 is also a horrible remoting solution, pretty much worse than every other possible option in every way. The only reason it seems anyone would even consider using it is because ssh has built-in support for it, or if you only use a handful of small Xaw3d or Motif applications with no graphics or bitmaps.
Re:Ask HN: When do you think Wayland will be broadly supported? by Amezarak on Saturday July 30, 2022 @08:19PM (#32291750)
> then I think you would have a lot worse problems in many other areas besides this.

I don't. I deal with many thousands of Linux servers. Batteries-included languages and X forwarded are my bread and butter. Losing the latter would make my job much, much worse. Of course, it would be nice to install random packages, but I can't.

> The only reason it seems anyone would even consider using it is because ssh has built-in support for it, or if you only use a handful of small Xaw3d or Motif applications with no graphics or bitmaps.

This is absolutely absurd and a completely ridiculous exaggeration approaching slander. I use perfectly normal, modern applications with X forwarding every day with zero issue, including web browsers (Firefox), image editors (GIMP), file managers (Dolphin), IDEs (Eclipse), various developer tools (MySQL Workbench) etc.

Frankly, a comment like this is shocking because it's plainly untrue.

> The only reason it seems anyone would even consider using it is because ssh has built-in support for it

This is a tremendously bigger upside than you seem to be giving credit for.

I'm going to just say it in this comment, because HN rate-limiting is hitting me, but none of the solutions you mentioned meet the criteria I described in the other post.