News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A media-fueled social panic over unmarked graves by bloaf on Friday July 29, 2022 @05:09PM (#32281814)
Quillette is cynically using the exact same "social-panic" tactics they're criticizing to create exactly your conclusion.

The Q article has exactly two complaints about the facts reported by the media:

1. The media claimed bodies were unearthed, when in fact only scans were taken.

2. The media claimed there were mass graves, when in fact scans only detected masses of individual graves.

However, in "social-panic" style, conservatives are taking these two quibbles over terminology and turning them into an Alex Jones-esque conspiracy to deny the graves existence altogether.

Note also the subtle racism in the article, where they compare a hypothetical instant-response to the murder of white children to the "very odd" response of the first nation people. The implication being that first nations people are incompetent, uncaring, or untrustworthy by not immediately doing a certain kind of investigation.

Re:A media-fueled social panic over unmarked graves by Cupertino95014 on Friday July 29, 2022 @05:12PM (#32281832)
> The media claimed bodies were unearthed

This is not a "quibble." It's a major falsehood.

Re:A media-fueled social panic over unmarked graves by bloaf on Friday July 29, 2022 @05:15PM (#32281856)
Unearth can be used in a literal sense, which in this case is false.

It can also be used in a figurative sense, which in this case is almost certainly true.

Re:A media-fueled social panic over unmarked graves by UIUC_06 on Friday July 29, 2022 @05:28PM (#32281979)
Don't get too dizzy from all that spinning around.

So do you really believe everyone in Canada read that and thought "Oh, they're using the word in a figurative sense! Never mind."

If something is, by definition, in the earth and a story says it was "unearthed" it's sorta reasonable to believe it was dug up.

Re:A media-fueled social panic over unmarked graves by munk-a on Friday July 29, 2022 @05:41PM (#32282088)
I actually think "unearthed" as in "discovered" is the more reasonable read - along with someone thinking they're clever in making a pun. When history is "unearthed" with radar, we generally assume some folks took a big expensive machine aimed it at the ground and walked away with a strong indication that something exists down there - when it comes to delicate items (like, for instance a decaying longboat that exists in the earth merely as concentrations of plant fiber in a suspicious shape) and especially when it comes to human remains (that people are often very reluctant to move due for cultural reasons) that's especially the case.
Re:A media-fueled social panic over unmarked graves by UIUC_06 on Friday July 29, 2022 @07:12PM (#32282743)
Yeah, I don't think most editors would think a pun about First Nation graves would be a clever idea.
Re:A media-fueled social panic over unmarked graves by prvc on Friday July 29, 2022 @05:49PM (#32282169)
What kind of journalist uses "unearthed" metaphorically in a story about purported graves?
Re:A media-fueled social panic over unmarked graves by smeej on Friday July 29, 2022 @05:14PM (#32281849)
The implication seemed (to me at least) to be that first nations people were not being afforded the same respect as their white counterparts would have been.
Re:A media-fueled social panic over unmarked graves by AinderS on Friday July 29, 2022 @05:16PM (#32281863)
> scans only detected masses of individual graves.

Possible graves. How many were unambiguously confirmed? And how many would we expect from normal high-at-the-time child mortality?

Re:A media-fueled social panic over unmarked graves by ZeroGravitas on Saturday July 30, 2022 @05:17AM (#32285409)
So the graves need to be confirmed, because you are skeptical they exist?

But if/when they are confirmed, then its not a big deal because it's just some of the graves that you know exist?

Do you see the contradiction here?

Re:A media-fueled social panic over unmarked graves by AinderS on Saturday July 30, 2022 @08:18AM (#32286214)
The contradiction in what? Wanting proof that the death rate was higher (and how much higher) than in any other school?
Re:A media-fueled social panic over unmarked graves by ZeroGravitas on Saturday July 30, 2022 @08:26AM (#32286250)
Do the graves only exist if the rate was higher?

You seem determined to downplay these graves, but the kettle logic of "these graves don't exist and also they do exist and we all know about them but they aren't a problem" undermines your argument.

Re:A media-fueled social panic over unmarked graves by AinderS on Saturday July 30, 2022 @09:27AM (#32286635)
Are you seriously going to pretend that these suspected graves aren't being used to allege that the treatment of natives in Canada was worse than previously believed?
Re:A media-fueled social panic over unmarked graves by ZeroGravitas on Saturday July 30, 2022 @11:55AM (#32287757)
Yes? I think people are just generally a little underinforned about this kind of stuff, so the actual details can be shocking.

And some people still overreact and try to cover it up and whitewash it.

The US Civil war being about slavery still seems to be considered an eleborate hoax to some people.

And they do the same "yes well the centuries of slavery, death, rape and murder is all true, and well established historical fact obviously, but <minor historical innaccuracy>! So basically they're overreacting and undermining our great nation by talking about stuff that happened." and it's cringe in both cases.