Re:Map showing birthplaces of "notable people" around the world
by ehnto on Friday July 29, 2022 @02:12PM
(#32280112)
It wasn't a criticism, of course something like this is limited by the data available and that's no the fault of the author. I was just musing on what might be a side effect of using what's available.
There wouldn't be a 'total complete and true set' of data for this task, since not all countries use wiki's to the same extent, and languages don't actually delineate between country (eg: Spanish wikipedia is not exclusively the view of people from Spain, nor is English wikipedia exclusively the views of people from England).
Re:Map showing birthplaces of "notable people" around the world
by Cd00d on Friday July 29, 2022 @02:26PM
(#32280248)
Sorry, I wasn't complaining about your post specifically, just a general tenor that kind of shits on this work because of an unsolvable problem: as you say there's actually no comprehensive dataset that would make it possible.
Your original comment was valid and insightful. I replied to it because it triggered a lot of secondary criticism about sample bias, and those are the comments I was most trying to respond to.
All datasets have bias. It's okay to acknowledge that and still find insights in the data.
Honestly curious: what highly accessible dataset that allows for the simple creations of 'fame metrics' would be better? I'm not aware of any.