News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wikipedia is currently in an edit war over the definition... by Mountain_Skies on Thursday July 28, 2022 @10:33PM (#32272538)
Not much of a surprise. We've spent the last two years redefining words, most with the tacit approval of even the majority of the crowd here, so why would it stop now?
Re:Wikipedia is currently in an edit war over the definition... by ALittleLight on Friday July 29, 2022 @12:45AM (#32273225)
Actually - "redefine" means to change the definition for political or arbitrary reasons. Language naturally evolves. All languages do and have. The fact that our language continues to evolve is unremarkable - that's not "redefining" anything.

Recession means two quarters of negative GDP growth while a Republican is President and basically always has. It doesn't apply here!

Re:Wikipedia is currently in an edit war over the definition... by tpoacher on Friday July 29, 2022 @11:34AM (#32278277)
I accept your redefinition for the definition of redefine, but you still haven't defined what you mean by define in the context of redefine to the extent that you redefined its definition.

Is define in your redefinition redefined to mean something other than the traditional definition of define as encountered in a redefine context? Or are you defining define within the redifinition of redefine as defined outside of the definition of your redefined redefine definition?

Re:Wikipedia is currently in an edit war over the definition... by coding123 on Saturday July 30, 2022 @01:21AM (#32284470)
At least one persons head exploded reading that.
Re:Wikipedia is currently in an edit war over the definition... by the_third_wave on Saturday July 30, 2022 @06:26AM (#32285642)
> Language naturally evolves. All languages do and have. The fact that our language continues to evolve is unremarkable - that's not "redefining" anything.

Language evolves, this is true. It is a slow and uncoordinated process which usually starts in a specific geographical location after which the changed words spread.

This is not what is happening here. The type of intentional and coordinated redefinitions of terms is not language evolution but language revolution - or revolutionary language, viz. Merriam Webster's recent redefinition of terms like 'female' [1], 'sexual preference' [2], 'anti-vaxxer' [3] and more.

[1] 'female' now includes the term 'having a gender identity that is the opposite of male' in a bid to appease transgender activists to allow them to answer the question 'what is a woman' with 'an adult human female'

[2] during the hearings for Supreme Court justice Amy Coney Barrett she (Barrett) used the term 'sexual preference' upon which the dictionary quickly modified the definition of the word 'preference' to include a claim that 'The term preference as used to refer to sexual orientation is widely considered offensive in its implied suggestion that a person can choose who they are sexually or romantically attracted to'

[3] this term was amended during the COVID vaccine mandate discussion by adding the claim that anyone who opposed vaccine mandates is an anti-vaxxer

Re:Wikipedia is currently in an edit war over the definition... by DuskStar on Friday July 29, 2022 @01:31AM (#32273466)
Absolutely fantastic. I bet that first paragraph gets said seriously within the year.
Re:Wikipedia is currently in an edit war over the definition... by throwaway0a5e on Friday July 29, 2022 @08:59AM (#32276276)
He didn't pull it out of nowhere. The reason it seems so spot on is because we've seen so many people on HN (and other places) say lightly paraphrased versions of that first paragraph so many times over the past several years.
Re:Wikipedia is currently in an edit war over the definition... by sethjr5rtfgh on Friday July 29, 2022 @10:18AM (#32277246)
> Actually - "redefine" means to change the definition for political or arbitrary reasons. Language naturally evolves. All languages do and have. The fact that our language continues to evolve is unremarkable - that's not "redefining" anything.

Actually, "redefine" means to change the definition regardless of the motive.

Re:Wikipedia is currently in an edit war over the definition... by tpoacher on Friday July 29, 2022 @11:36AM (#32278306)
For suitable definitions of define and redefine that are not redefined definitions of the original definitions as defined by definition, yes.
Re:Wikipedia is currently in an edit war over the definition... by niknoble on Friday July 29, 2022 @04:53AM (#32274572)
The tone of the first paragraph is spot on and had me fully convinced. I wasn't even surprised when I read it. I just felt the usual low-level disappointment that I've felt whenever reading any mainstream news, art, advertising, etc over the last 2 years.
Re:Wikipedia is currently in an edit war over the definition... by LeafItAlone on Friday July 29, 2022 @12:52AM (#32273264)
What other words are being or have been redefined in the past two years?
Re:Wikipedia is currently in an edit war over the definition... by tpoacher on Friday July 29, 2022 @11:47AM (#32278464)
Scott Adams recently had a podcast on this topic:

"All major topics have at least one word that is critical to our debate, that we don't use the same way."

"Words That Don’t Have Meaning Anymore, So We Can Stop Debating Them": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SGIUUzDj3hU (about 5 minutes in).

The words were:

- Woman - Find (i.e. discover vs make up) - Insurrection - Fascism - Autonomy - Phobic - Racist - Vaccine - Meeting - Baby - Evidence - Audit - Science - Healthy - Rights

Re:Wikipedia is currently in an edit war over the definition... by ccrush on Sunday July 31, 2022 @05:58AM (#32294495)
Woman in Merriam Webster was changed recently.
Re:Wikipedia is currently in an edit war over the definition... by baisq on Friday July 29, 2022 @05:07AM (#32274655)
Woman: a pretty big one!
[dead]
Re:Wikipedia is currently in an edit war over the definition... by ChadNauseam on Friday July 29, 2022 @04:31AM (#32274431)
can you elaborate on how “vaccine” has been redefined in the past few years?
Re:Wikipedia is currently in an edit war over the definition... by niknoble on Friday July 29, 2022 @05:08AM (#32274658)
Apparently the CDC literally changed its definition. From the Miami Herald (but you can check against other sources):

> Before the change, the definition for “vaccination” read, “the act of introducing a vaccine into the body to produce immunity to a specific disease.” Now, the word “immunity” has been switched to “protection.” The term “vaccine” also got a makeover. The CDC’s definition changed from “a product that stimulates a person’s immune system to produce immunity to a specific disease” to the current “a preparation that is used to stimulate the body’s immune response against diseases.”

Webster dictionary broadened its definition too. From USA Today:

> Merriam-Webster revised its "vaccine" definition to replace "immunity" with "immune response."

Re:Wikipedia is currently in an edit war over the definition... by epakai on Friday July 29, 2022 @06:31PM (#32282486)
What were non-immunizing vaccines called before? I've seen "intramuscular virus injection", but I don't think that was ever a layman's term.

Have we not always had the concept of sterilising immunity, and therefore non-sterilising immunity?

To me this is just nuance being exposed, and word definitions being updated to include that nuance.

Re:Wikipedia is currently in an edit war over the definition... by the_third_wave on Saturday July 30, 2022 @06:31AM (#32285671)
They were called "non-immunising vaccines". viz. this article from 2001:

Development of a non-immunising, paraspecific vaccine from attenuated pox viruses: a new type of vaccine

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12578306/

Re:Wikipedia is currently in an edit war over the definition... by mixmastamyk on Friday July 29, 2022 @06:38PM (#32282537)
Why is the grandparent flagged/dead for an arguably innocuous comment, that others are allowed to make? I've seen this a lot recently, wonder what is going on?
Re:Wikipedia is currently in an edit war over the definition... by the_third_wave on Saturday July 30, 2022 @06:36AM (#32285686)
Probably the same as what is happening at Wikipedia, over-zealous users have taken it upon themselves to police certain topics and punish certain users for expressing their opinions which go against the desired narrative.