News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Higher order derivatives in everyday life? by BrandoElFollito on Thursday July 28, 2022 @12:25PM (#32266525)
During the COVID pandemic, I saw some truly magical statistics in our government (I am French).

I tried to understand some of their data but it was beyond my capacities - despite having access to some raw data. I do not think that the general population cared (the concern was rather on how to calculate 1 km from their house) but for someone who is allergic to bad statistics creating crappy results it was torture.

Re:Ask HN: Higher order derivatives in everyday life? by inasio on Thursday July 28, 2022 @02:03PM (#32268040)
I used to work doing epidemic models, it was torture sometimes to see people abuse mathematical concepts (eigenvalues, r0, etc) when talking about covid
Re:Ask HN: Higher order derivatives in everyday life? by BrandoElFollito on Thursday July 28, 2022 @02:40PM (#32268507)
We had an expert one on TV answering questions, and one of the questions was the one I was burning to ask: "how do you know there are X infections per day"?

To what he answers "because we get data from pharmacies, doctors, etc. about cases"

- so how do you know that this is a total number? It is just the number of positive tests?

- yes, so we know the ratio and therefore can tell for the whole population

- so the number you provide is an estimate?

- no, the number of cases

(some time passed and then another question)

- when you extrapolate (they used a more human-friendly term), how do you know that the ones who come for tests are representative of the whole population

- ...

While I must say that our government reacted to the pandemic almost very well (except that they lied at the beginning), some of the experts they put ahead were ridiculous.

Re:Ask HN: Higher order derivatives in everyday life? by yoyopa on Thursday July 28, 2022 @09:29PM (#32272117)
who was asking the questions?
Re:Ask HN: Higher order derivatives in everyday life? by BrandoElFollito on Saturday July 30, 2022 @04:53PM (#32290203)
It was a "round table" kind of show with experts from the government, academia, science journalists etc.

It was interesting because it raised the right questions but unfortunately dd not beiring any answers.